Monday, September 26, 2005

Scholarship and pederasty: an update

The other day, I wrote about a controversy surrounding Haworth Press's decision to drop a book, Same-Sex Desire and Love in Greco-Roman Antiquity and in the Classical Tradition of the West, after the far-right website WorldNetDaily raised a ruckus about an essay in the book which argued that sexual relationships between adult men and adolescent boys should not be viewed as harmful or wrong.

An article in today's Chronicle of Higher Education examines the brouhaha. (Thanks to author David Glenn for the tip; unfortunately I'm not sure the link will work for non-subscribers.)

Some excerpts:

Last Wednesday, two days after WorldNetDaily's condemnation, the press announced that it had canceled the book. Kathryn Rutz, Haworth's vice president for editorial development, said in an e-mail message to The Chronicle that five of the press's top officials had made the decision.

The press received approximately 20 messages of complaint in the two days after the WorldNetDaily attack, Ms. Rutz said. She added, however, that "it is likely that this would have come up later in the production process, even without the input of outside correspondents."

The decision to cancel was not easy, Ms. Rutz said. "There was vigorous discussion, to be sure," she said. "Issues on the table included freedom of speech, consequences of negative publicity, personal objections to the subject matter, and resistance to what might appear to be caving in to a particular group with its own right-wing agenda."

.......

In 1998 Mr. Rind and two colleagues published an article in the Psychological Bulletin, a journal of the American Psychological Association, in which they reviewed 59 previously published studies of college students who had been victims of child sexual abuse. In their analysis, Mr. Rind and his colleagues found that not all of the students had suffered lasting psychological harm, and that 42 percent of the male students retrospectively viewed their sexual experiences with adults as "positive."

The paper came under immediate and heavy criticism from other scholars of sexual abuse. Among other things, scholars objected that studies of college students were not the best way to capture the full range of experiences of abused children. The following summer, after a campaign by talk-radio hosts, the paper was denounced in unanimous resolutions by both houses of the U.S. Congress.

....

Other critics of Mr. Rind's work have pointed to a 1995 essay of his published in Paidika, an obscure, explicitly pro-pedophilic journal. In that article, Mr. Rind called for the abolition of age-of-consent laws. One condemnation of that essay appeared in Haworth's own Journal of Child Sexual Abuse in 2002.


I remember the outcry over Rind's 1998 article. Some of the hysteria was over the top, particularly the congressional resolution (there are plenty of other articles in academic journals that express fairly outrageous viewpoints without incurring the same kind of condemnation). However, as some scholars quoted by Glenn point out, the issue is not just the conclusion (shared by many other researchers) that many victims of child sexual abuse make it to adulthood with no enduring trauma; it's that Rind and his co-authors seemed to cross the line from research into advocacy. The Paidika essay, of which I was previously unaware, makes it clear that Rind (an adjunct psychology instructor at Temple University) crossed that line a long time ago.

One contributor to the canceled volume, Amy Richlin, a professor of classics at the University of California at Los Angeles, was quoted in the Chronicle as saying of Haworth Press, "If they're going to allow themselves to be held hostage to the radical right, then they should get out of the publishing business." So now, being against the normalization of man/boy sex marks you as a member of the radical right? I would estimate that on this issue, some 99% of the public would agree with WND. And why give ammunition to enemies of gay rights who are always using the specter of pedophile acceptance as a scare tactic?

13 comments:

sierra said...

This inquiry into the effects of pedophilia masquerades as science the same way intelligent design does.

hanly said...

Blu Ray Converter
Convert Blu Ray to AVI
Convert Blu Ray to MKV
Convert Blu Ray to MOV
Convert Blu Ray to MP4

Larah said...

Checking midterm paper I understand that scholarship is very difficult issue.

Permana said...

Obat Stroke Iskemik Herbal Alami adalah sebuah solusi untuk anda yang bingung mencari obat untuk mengatasi penyakit stroke, selain itu ada juga Obat Untuk Mengobati Stroke Ringan Herbal yang memang banyak dicari karena sekarang ini banyak sekali penderita penyakit stroke ringan. Obat Stroke Tradisional Alami Ampuh, memang sangat ampuh karena terbuat dari bahan-bahan tradisional. Obat Untuk Stroke Ringan Yang Manjur juga sangat ampuh untuk mengatasi stroke ringan. Untuk itu Obat Penyakit Stroke Alami dan Tradisional sangat membantu sekali untuk pengobatan penyakit stroke. Obat Mujarab Untuk mengobati Penyakit Stroke merupakan sebuah obat mujarab yang banyak dijadikan alternatif oleh banyak orang, Obat Penyakit Stroke Alami dan Tradisional dan Obat Alami Untuk Mengobati Penyakit Stroke ini sudah banyak membantu orang-orang yang mengidap penyakit stroke dengan menggunakan Obat Untuk Penyakit Stroke Paling Ampuh. Obat Herbal Untuk Penderita Penyakit Stroke ini sangat aman, karena terbuat dari bahan alami yang 100% herbal. Obat Tradisional Untuk Penyakit Stroke Berat pun tersedia untuk anda yang memang mengalmai stroke berat. Untuk itu baik Obat Tradisional Untuk Menyembuhkan Penyakit Stroke, Obat Untuk Mengobati Stroke Ringan Maupun Berat, ataupun Obat Herbal Yang Mampu Untuk Mengobati Penyakit Stroke sangat baik dan berkhasiat sangat tinggi untuk mengobati penyakit stroke hingga tuntas.

Unknown said...

Hotmail is an email account of Microsoft Corporation. Like Google's Gmail, it is full of features usually xuyen.Neu of an email you want to register an account please follow these basic steps:
Hotmail login

Hotmail review

Sign in to hotmail

Login to hotmail

Recover hotmail password

Tank Trouble is a very interesting flash game about tanks, about war and about destruction
TANK TROUBLE | TANK TROUBLE 2

One Penguin Takes it personally when he is surfing the web and stumbles upon a web site telling him that he cant fly, after that he sets his mind to research and practice flying until he can prove the world that he can..
Slitherio | LEARN TO FLY | LEARN TO FLY 2

Strike Force Heroes is a new game action-packed shooter from the creators of Raze; with 3 game modes, 15 campaign missions and over 65 weapons.
Strike Force Heroes | Strike Force Heroes 4

Strike Force Heroes 2

Sophie Grace said...

I enjoyed over read your blog post. Your blog have nice information, I got good ideas from this amazing blog. I am always searching like this type blog post. I hope I will see again.. Coming to interesting game sims 4 cheats on PLaystation 4

Murat BATTAL said...

Web tasarım
Grafik tasarım
Web tasarım
Grafik tasarım
Web yazılım
Kurumsal Kimlik Tasarımı
Logo tasarım
Tile levelling system
Floor drains
Aluminium profiles
Tile spacers
Women's clothes and lingeries
Textile and cheap accesorries
Sanitation products
Health products
Circular Blades
Straight Blades
Razor Blades
Guillotine Blades
Machine Knives
Industrial Blades
Punch Knives
Paper Cutting Blades
Packaging Blades
Plastic Cutting Blades
evden eve nakliyat
istanbul evden eve nakliyat fiyatları
şehirler arası evden eve nakliyat
ev eşya depolama şirketi
istanbul ofis taşıma firmaları
şehiriçi evden eve nakliye
antalya pedogog
antalya psikolojik danışman
antalya psikolojik testler
antalya ergen danışmanlığı
antalya psikolog
antalya çocuk pedagog
antalya çocuk danışmanlığı
antalya yetişkin psikolog
Siirt klima servisi
Siirt Beyaz Eşya Servisi
Siirt Klima Bayi
Siirt Klima montaj ve tamir
Siirt Soğutma

Murat BATTAL said...

Web tasarım
Grafik tasarım
Web tasarım
Grafik tasarım
Web yazılım
Kurumsal Kimlik Tasarımı
Logo tasarım
Tile levelling system
Floor drains
Aluminium profiles
Tile spacers
Women's clothes and lingeries
Textile and cheap accesorries
Sanitation products
Health products
Circular Blades
Straight Blades
Razor Blades
Guillotine Blades
Machine Knives
Industrial Blades
Punch Knives
Paper Cutting Blades
Packaging Blades
Plastic Cutting Blades
evden eve nakliyat
istanbul evden eve nakliyat fiyatları
şehirler arası evden eve nakliyat
ev eşya depolama şirketi
istanbul ofis taşıma firmaları
şehiriçi evden eve nakliye
antalya pedogog
antalya psikolojik danışman
antalya psikolojik testler
antalya ergen danışmanlığı
antalya psikolog
antalya çocuk pedagog
antalya çocuk danışmanlığı
antalya yetişkin psikolog
Siirt klima servisi
Siirt Beyaz Eşya Servisi
Siirt Klima Bayi
Siirt Klima montaj ve tamir
Siirt Soğutma

Ashwin Krishna said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice blog, As per my experience India Assignment Help is an amazing platform where you can get Assignment Help And Homework Help services for any topic and for any subject like engineering, accounting, geography, history, English, and so on. They provide the services like Essay Writing Help, Accounting Assignment Help , Finance Assignment Helpdissertations, thesis, presentations, research, case studies and much more.
Read Related Article

Ashwin Krishna said...

As the complete form explains, the Statement of Purpose Format is an essay stating the purpose of applying to a particular course in a specific university. Some Big Service providers providing Assignment Help and SOP Writing Help also. It is for mainly those students applying internationally. An SOP needs to be highly well-constructed, depicting clarity of thought in the language used. The professionals emphasise stressing some essential elements which is help to design a perfect Statement of Purpose Sample
Read Related Article

Ashwin Krishna said...

There are a lot of companies in the market which provide Accounting Assignment Help.
such as India Assignment Help which is specifically designed for the Indian students. They are delivering successfully Assignment Help for more than 10+ years. They also provide some of the additional services which could be availed by the students while booking the assignments such as Free revisions, 100% original and unique contents, fresh ideas, expert assistance, 24 X 7 customer support.

Assignment Helper said...

I like this website. I am glad that I landed here. Let me tell you one thing. If you want Math Homework Help, then you should spend your time looking for a good Assignment Help, website instead of wasting your time here. Marketing is a subject that does not require any introduction. It is such a general subject like essay help & academic writing help that seems as if it is quite common, yet it is quite specific.
READ RELATED ARTICLE.

Ashwin Krishna said...

There is a team of academic writers at India Assignment Help who have been assisting students in a better way. The team of in- house subject-specific offers the prominent Assignment Help and Homework Help services. They all are keen on researching and drafting assignments they can write on any topic. They have a team of experts also who have qualified from the best universities in the world. Many students have encountered difficulties in Major subjects Like Law Assignment Help , Accounting Assignment Help and Finance Assignment Help.

Read Related Article