Thursday, September 22, 2005

Hurricanes and feminism?

No, this is not a joke (at least, not an intentional one). Hurricanes and feminism. If you thought the racial politics of Katrina were absurd, wait till you see the gender spin.

In the days after the disaster, there was a rather animated discussion of Hurricane Katrina on the Women's Studies List, an email forum/subscription list for women's studies professors and instructors. There, along with standard rhetoric about racism and the awfulness of Bush ("The silver lining is that the Bush administration is completely under fire right now"), there was a lot talk about how to analyze the tragedy in class as a feminist issue.

Funny, I thought that hurricanes and natural disasters in general are pretty gender-neutral (at least now that hurricanes are given both male and female names). But no: "Please," wrote one professor, "let us recognize that the most vulnerable people that were impacted by this disaster were women, such as the disabled, the mothers with infants, the elderly woman in her wheelchair who was left to die, while her rotting corpse was covered over in a white sheet." I will concede that due to high rates of single motherhood in poor urban neighborhoods, there were undboutedly more women in New Orleans who were sole caretakers of small children. But disability is now a female condition? Elderly men in wheelchairs didn't die?

If there was a "women's issue" here, it was the fact that in the lawless atmosphere that followed the flood, women in general were almost certainly more vulnerable to crime and to sex crimes in particular (though men were probably under greater pressure to act as protectors of women and children; and there are media accounts of female perpetrators of violence, as well). But interestingly, the women's studies list discussion glossed over that, since to condemn violence and lawlessness would be racially un-PC, and women's studies is rigidly bound by the leftist orthodoxy of identity politics of all kinds. (For a great analysis of the topic, see Professing Feminism: Education and Indoctrination in Women's Studies by former Women's Studies professors Daphne Patai and Noretta Koertge.) The same prof whose comment is cited above went on to say, "And, with regards to GENDER, please let's not forget how black MEN and BOYS were cast in a most familiar trope of criminality through images of 'looting' and 'lawlessness.'"

Others on the list speculated that the federal government ignored Louisiana governor Kathleen Blanco's plea for help because, heck, she's just a woman (though Blanco failed the sisterhood test for being so insensitive as to criticize the people who didn't evacuate and for endorsing a shoot-to-kill policy on looters). Then there was this observation:

Another aspect of the disaster that could be construed as a feminist issue is the ridiculous misuse of our country's resources and tax-dollars which have been poured into a pointless war by a male dominated "war-mongering" government. On a spiritual level the feminine principle has been thrown seriously out of balance by a government which never had any intention of nurturing, protecting, or supporting its own people.

War is male, nurturing is female; gotta love the clich├ęs. (Condoleeza Rice, of course, is not a "real woman" on this list.)

Someone also brought up a class discussion of "ecofeminism," "Mother Earth," and "the Goddess."

So, in asking students to think how urban planning, development, and responses to natural disasters would be conceived differently if we viewed our planet as a living Terra Madre (Mother Earth), they began to add a different dimension to feminist analysis of this tragedy.

Many imagined that everything, from saving the wetlands of New Orleans, to placing emphasis on redesigning a city for safety with housing and levees that were built to guard against the wrath of hurricanes, would have been in place.

...

It has also allowed us to "think globally" in terms of the global warming that will increase the frequency of hurricanes like Katrina and the ways in which even Nature enters into the realm of politics...

Bet you didn't know that building levees to guard against hurricanes required particularly feminist thinking.

Luckily, unlike the race-baiting of the Al Sharptons and the Randall Robinsons, the rhetoric of the feminist wing of the looney left rarely seeps into the mainstream, largely staying confined to the nutty professors and their students. Sadly, however, this is a stark example of feminism marginalizing itself. Is there any wonder that most young women in college today regard it as an "F-word"?

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

Funny, I assumed putting in levees and other flood control measures raped the Earth.

Sarah said...

One of the first questions I asked myself in my college classes was "will this stuff actually help me (or anyone else) at all?" If the class seemed like self-congratulatory nonsense, I dropped it. This may explain why I don't have any credits in women's studies, and have a whole lot of them in science courses.

Anonymous said...

Just a quick note: WMST has over 4,000 subscribers and not all of them particpate in every conversation. In my opinion, the hurricane thread was ridiculous, but I didn't have the time or engry to engage in a debate...

Unknown said...

Welcome to http://www.mmoggg.de website to buy RS Gold, offer a lot, of course, Diablo 3 Gold or Diablo 3 Gold Kaufen and WoW Gold, to be purchased at any time, at any time shipment, and look forward to your visit!

love thomass said...

I feel my ideas and methods may be a problem, but very confused and do not know how to do, so ask the experts how to grow up.You can learn more: China vacation packages | China tour operator

Unknown said...

Once you Guild Wars 2 Gold in WvW area, your current degree automatically modifications to be able to 50, but with out making innovative skills and equipment Buy D3 Gold.Even though fights are really massive factor that's not about brainless important key right after switch as well as running aimlessly for the battlefield.

Ashwin Krishna said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice blog, As per my experience India Assignment Help is an amazing platform where you can get Assignment Help And Homework Help services for any topic and for any subject like engineering, accounting, geography, history, English, and so on. They provide the services like Essay Writing Help, Accounting Assignment Help dissertations, thesis, presentations, research, case studies and much more.

Ashwin Krishna said...

SOP writing help you establish yourself as a more potential candidate for the course over thousands of other candidates. A majority share of the admission selection relies on how well is your statement of purpose. To aid you achieve that, we offer our SOP writing help India pack to all. Students often hire the SOP Writing Help. They search for Statement of Purpose Format so that they could take ideas of how to write a perfect Statement of Purpose. You can contact us to know the best Statement of Purpose Sample

Assignment Helper said...

If You are a Student and looking for Assignment Help then My Assignment Services is the best choice among students for all their academic needs as we deliver Assignment Help services like cpm homework help, Homework Help and write my essay and many more with unparalleled features.

1. 24/7 Support
2. Quality Gurantee
3. Services for All Subjects

Ashwin Krishna said...

Thanks for such a valuable information. Some students find it difficult to get through the SOP Writing Help. Due to this, they need assistance from professionals who can aid them in their SOP Writing Help. Writing a statement of purpose is one of the difficult tasks and is considered a challenge for most students. A lot of students fail during writing the statement of purpose format hence they search for a Statement of purpose sample .

READ RELATED ARTICLE.

Assignment Helper said...

Our online Assignment Help experts come from a diversity of professional backgrounds. Our homework assignment help for students team is constituted of experts who have experience in construction, manufacturing, IT, etc among other major industries. For example, our Write My Essay experts have worked in almost every part of the country and abroad as well. This brings a wealth of examples that can be included in your assignment.
Read Related Article

Lenny Hofsad said...

The BTEC Assignment Help guide is an excellent resource for students who are looking to improve their academic performance. The guide provides practical tips on how to structure and present ideas effectively, use credible sources, and avoid plagiarism. It's a must-read for anyone who wants to achieve academic success.

Unknown said...

It's important to remember that in the wake of a hurricane, access to medical care can be severely impacted. This is particularly true for women, who may face additional challenges in accessing healthcare. It's essential that steps are taken to ensure doctor availability in the aftermath of natural disasters, especially for vulnerable populations.

Lenny Hofsad said...

I appreciate the author's emphasis on originality and avoiding plagiarism in HNC assignments. This is an important aspect of academic integrity, and the HNC Assignment Help guide provides helpful tips for ensuring that your work is entirely your own.

Lenny Hofsad said...

Acquire Help with Holmes T1 2023 Final Assessments online from experienced and qualified tutors and score maximum marks. Enroll for expert service and book a slot of expert who will write your final assignment attractive and effective to score maximum marks. The experts are available around the clock for quick help in your final assignment.

Palak Mittal said...

Really a great & helpful post!
Looking for Architecture assignment help? Our expert team of architects and designers can assist you in completing your assignments with precision and creativity. Get professional guidance and achieve top grades in your architecture studies.

Amelia Peterson said...

It is somewhat common to draft wrong solutions in your Diploma assessment jobs and homework tasks, because of its intricacies and mathematical approaches. Are you one of those who are bothering with your allocated academic work? Do you need a helping hand to resolve your academic worries? Don't worry; Diploma Assignment Help is always at your doorstep to help you in the best possible manner and assure you nothing but A++grades every time!

Diana gates said...

With a track record of delivering high-quality solutions and meeting tight deadlines, we take pride in helping students and professionals excel in their programming courses and projects. Our experts are well-versed in various programming languages, including Python, Java, C++, and more. Don't let those assignments stress you out any longer. Trust us to provide you with clear, well-commented, and efficient code solutions that will not only earn you top grades but also enhance your understanding of programming concepts.

Reach out to us today for Programming Assignment Help, and let's embark on a successful coding journey together. Your success is our priority!"

Diana gates said...

If you're seeking top-notch assistance with your Financial Services assignment, look no further! The world of finance can be intricate, but our expert team is here to guide you through every concept and calculation. Whether it's analyzing market trends, understanding risk management strategies, or unraveling the complexities of financial derivatives, we've got you covered. Our dedicated professionals bring a wealth of experience to the table and are committed to helping you grasp the finer points of the subject. With our Financial Services assignment help, you'll not only submit assignments on time but also gain a deeper comprehension of the financial world. Get ready to excel academically and embark on a journey towards mastering financial services!

The Assignment Helpline said...

Our Custom Coursework Writing Service offers professional assistance to students seeking high-quality academic papers. Get expert help today.

Diana gates said...

Macroeconomics is a fascinating field that explores the intricate workings of entire economies. If you're looking for help with your macroeconomics assignment help, you're in the right place! Our team of experts is well-versed in the theories, models, and real-world applications of macroeconomics. Whether you're grappling with concepts like GDP, inflation, unemployment, fiscal policy, or monetary policy, we've got you covered. We can provide you with comprehensive explanations, insightful analyses, and well-researched data to support your assignment.

Amelia Peterson said...

Are you not sure of completing a well-written and high quality solution document related to BTEC course academic tasks? Are you in search for a way to finish up effectively and timely? Leave all your academic worries aside and approach towards BTEC Assignment Help and get comprehensive guidance to complete your job in such a way that you will never secure less than A++ in your academics!!

henry said...

Get top-notchUnited Arab Emirates University Assignment Help from experts. Score high grades with our professional assistance.

Expertsminds said...

Are you looking for expert guidance to ace your marketing assignments ? Our specialized assistance ensures top-notch support, insightful strategies, and comprehensive solutions to elevate your marketing game. Let's collaborate and conquer those assignments together!

henry said...

Explore captivating humanities essay sample that delve into the depths of human culture, history, and philosophy.