Tuesday, August 14, 2007

Race, educational achievement, and affirmative action

According to a repot in Inside Higher Ed, the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association was focused on "new reseach designed to shift the debate" on affirmative action. The main point of this shift: repealing affirmative action, the new argument goes, is unfair not simply because it results in a drop of black and Latino enrollment at the top universities, but because this drop is not related to merit.

Robert T. Teranishi, assistant professor of higher education at New York University, said that his research was designed to counter the “blaming the victim” mentality in which he said people assume black enrollment declines suggest a lack of merit by black students.

The reality, he said, is that a new form of school segregation has taken hold in which in post-affirmative action California, the best way for a black or Latino student to get into a University of California campus is to attend a “white” high school.

Teranishi’s research focuses on California high schools and the relationship between attending high schools with certain characteristics and enrolling at a University of California campus. He started by noting that while California is famous for its ethnic and racial diversity (in statewide totals), 88 percent of high schools have a racial majority of one group. Of those schools, he said, 44.7 percent have a white majority, while 43.4 percent have a black or Latino majority. But among new University of California students, 65.3 percent come from white majority schools and only 21.7 percent come from black or Latino majority schools.

From there, Teranishi presented data showing educational inequities in the different kinds of schools, such as studies showing that the greater the proportion of black and Latino students in a high school, the fewer Advanced Placement courses that are likely to be offered.

The cumulative impact of these inequities is such that minority students who are admitted to top University of California campuses are more likely to have attended white majority schools than other schools. At Berkeley, for example, 48.9 percent of the underrepresented minority students admitted attended white majority high schools, while 33.6 percent attended high schools that were black or Latino majority and 17.5 percent attended high schools without a racial majority. At the University of California at San Diego, the percentage of new black and Latino students coming from white majority high schools is 52.6 percent.

Teranishi said that such data should shake up people who think that some pure idea of merit is at play in selecting the best students for top colleges. Is it fair to tell black and Latino students, he asked, that to have a good chance at getting into UCLA or Berkeley, “they need to attend a white school"?

Walter Allen, professor of higher education at UCLA, said that what the data suggest are that admissions systems supposedly designed to favor merit are in fact systems that “protect privilege” and end up ripping off black and Latino people generally — either as would-be students or as taxpayers. “The poor folks are subsidizing the educations of wealthy people,” he said.

A few things leap out. First, the blatantly agenda-driven nature of the research, explicitly -- by the researcher's own admission -- designed to support a particular public policy goal (the defense of race-based preferences in college admissions). Second, the blatantly one-sided nature of the discussion at the conference (at least judging by Scott Jaschik's account at Inside Higher Ed, no opposing viewpoints were presented).

And thirdly, I think the esteemed sociologists have the wrong idea about opposition to preferences. Few Americans regard "merit" as a completely innate quality that exists outside any social or cultural context, and the idea of innate racial differences in intelligence is generally quite unpopular among critics of race-based preferences. Most of those critics, such as Abigail and Stephan Thernstrom, have stressed the need to reform K-12 education rather than try to artificially remedy the educational achievement gap by lowering college admission standards for minorities.


Teranishi's research (disputed by some people in the comments at Inside Higher Ed) is intriguing; but it hardly proves that the students who are being rejected by the top colleges are qualified for admission. The availability of advanced placement courses, and resources in general, is undoubtedly a factor; but there may be other reasons black and Latino students from majority white schools do better -- such as a school culture more supportive of scholastic achievement.

Instead of renewing the call for crude racial-preference policies, it might be worth it to look at what those majority-white schools are doing right.

My own article on racial preferences, from 2001, can be found here.

23 comments:

Anonymous said...

You have absolutely struck on something here. And that is, in the Latino (or Black) communities, academics is not a priority.
Give these kids a break. Make them attend a Japanese/Korean/Chinese school. Let them spend a few nights a week in these ethnic homes. Let the light bulb come on in their heads.
Guess what kids in the Asian families do at night?
THEY STUDY!! Their parents push them to do ALL of their homework, AND MORE!!
My kids are 50% Korean. They are very bright and at the top of their class. We have noticed the performance data by ethnic group for high schools in our area. We avoid sending our kids to the heavily latino or black schools, for one very simple reason. This environment is not conducive to high academic performance. It is a CULTURAL DIFFERENCE.

colagirl said...

My own experience teaching first-year undergrads at a fairly large institution--sadly, often it seemed that the minority students I had in my classes were less prepared for college-level work than their white or Asian counterparts (although not always, by any means). In terms of writing skills--spelling and punctuation, sentence and paragraph construction, and reading comprehension, they often lagged behind. They also tended to have worse attendance records, and worse records of work completion. I still remember one student--he was one of the most talkative in class, really demonstrated an engagement with the material, vitally contributed to and stimulated class discussion--but he ended up failing the class because he didn't turn in any of the major assignments and I couldn't grade him on work I hadn't received.

I've heard it argued that affirmative action can set such students up for failure, by getting them into universities where they can't keep up with the work, so for example a student that might have done just fine at a Tier II university gets into a Tier I institution because of AA and ends up flunking out. Or that AA encourages students to immediately attend four-year institutions who might have benefited from a year or so at a community college to get their writing and studying skills up to snuff. I think there's some truth to that. The impulse behind AA is a good one, but no one's interests are served by admitting unqualified students--least of all the interests of the students themselves, who have been set up to fail instead of taught how to achieve.

LtRand said...

I find it amusing that the answer they never come up with is to push and reform the minority ethnic schools to perform at higher levels and to actually expect the students to do it and fail them if they don't. Of course, that would be the white-privilage speaking, wouldn't it?

Anonymous said...

it is not the schools that are failing. it is the parents, or perhaps the single mom.
they don't make their kids study.
it is as simple as that.
the asian cultures do, and that is why the kids do so well.
it is not rocket science.

ada47 said...

H Cathy
SO glad you're back!

I'd like to see an honest assessment of whether affirmatie action works.

My sense is that it has accomplished neither the good that its supporters claim, nor the bad that its detractors claim. But that is just my gut, and if I did everything by my gut, I guess I'd be, like, maybe, President or something. I'd like to see the numbers, though in this case it is almost certainly difficult to determine whether any gains have been caused by AA, or what the failures mean.

Here's an interesting observation, though perhanps an aside. I'm on the faculty at an elite university that has Division I athletics. Of course, we have to lower our academic standard somehwat to ensure that all of our team rosters get filled. This tends to enrage much of the faculty (personaly, I don' care), while it is generally supported by more conservtive students, alums, donors and adminstrators. On the other hand, "diversity" admissions, which lower the academic standards to increase the representation of certain racialor ethnic minorities, are enthusiastically supported by the faculty and less so by the more conservative students, alums and donors.

Well, it's too late at night and I have too much work to do to ponder what all that means, but I thought I'd throw it out there.

Cathy Young said...

Thanks for the comments everyone; and ada47, good to be back. You raise a very interesting question about breaks for athletes being to conservatives/traditionalists what breaks for minorities are to liberals.

Revenant said...

I hadn't thought of sports fans as a particularly "conservative" crowd. The average fan is more conservative than the average academic -- but then, the average Democrat is more conservative than the average academic too.

Cathy Young said...

Rev, I do think that generally it's liberals who tend criticize the prominence of athletics on college campuses (often in conjunction with a critique of "male-dominated culture"), while conservatives tend to defend it.

However, it's also useful to remember that the NAACP has staunchly opposed efforts to link athletic scholarships to some minimal standards of academic performance.

Adi said...

thanks for sharing this info. greets from Pandeglang. Pandeglang is one of many places in Indonesia are eligible for tourist destination.
Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang Objek Wisata di Pandeglang Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang Pantai Carita Seni Saman Rampak Bedug

James Taylor said...

brochure design | logo design | business logo design

James Taylor said...

custom logo | stationery design

nike said...

Rubber. Rubber is widly used in the outsole of the athletic shoes.
cheap puma shoes
cheap sport shoes
discount puma shoes
It has the advantages of durable, skipproof, flexible, elastic, extensive, stable and proper hardness.
But the rubber is weighty and easy to be frosting, nonrecoverable.
nike shox torch
nike tn dollar
cheap nike shox
PU. PU is a kind of macromolecule polyurethane materials which is offten used in the midsole of basktball shoes and tennis shoes.
cheap nike shox shoes
nike shox r4
puma mens shoes
Sometimes, it is also used in the outsole of casual shoes.
PU is durable, strong hardness, upstanding flexbility and more important, it is environmentally friendly.
cheap nike max
discount nike shox
cheap puma ferrari shoes
The disadvantage is also outstanding. Strong hydroscopic property, go yellow easily, easily break apart and the sole is putrescible.
EVA. Ethylene –Vinyl Acetate Copolymer,a kind of macromolecule polyurethane materials
nike mens shoes
nike shox nz
discount nike running shoes
which is usually used in the midsole of the running shoes and casual shoes.
EVA is quite lightweight, elastic, flexible and suitable to a variety of climates.
discount nike shoes
nike shox shoes
cheap nike shoes
Just as the rubber, it is also nonrecoverable and go dirty easily.
PHYLON. Phylon is the product of the EVA after the second processing.
nike sports shoes
puma running shoes
puma sneakers
The midsole of running shoes, tennis shoes and basketball shoes in the world is made of the PHYLON.
nike air max tn
puma cat
puma shoes
The upstanding hardness, density, traction and extension make it favorite by the manufacture.
Besides, the lightweight and good flexibility could prolong the life of the shoes.
nike running shoes
wholesale nike shoes
nike shoes
Just as a coin has two sides, Phylon is nonrecoverable and easily shrink under high temperature.
TPR. The TPR is made of TPR kernel after fusion. This kind of materials is usually made to running shoes and casual shoes.
nike shoes kids
nike women shoes

nike said...

You will never find swimsuit more excellent than in Ed Hardy!
ed hardy ugg boots
ed hardy love kills slowly boots
ed hardy love kills slowly
We provide you with the sexiest swimwear at present. Wanting to be bright on beach in this
ed hardy polo shirts
ed hardy love kills slowly shoes
ed hardy wear
Abandoning traditional concepts on sexy swimwear, Ed Hardy adds tattoo upon, which is meaning
how your outline if only you like now! Genuine material admits you to throw your whole worr
ed hardy love kills slowly shirts
ed hardy trousers
ed hardy jackets
It seems that ed hardy mens shoes was difficult to be able to let you exist out in swimwear, the
just fold, flouncing, bow and swim suits, Ed Hardy has been widely worn in open.
ed hardy t shirts sale
ed hardy womens t shirts
ed hardy boots
In the trunks term, the Panerai candy-flush has mainly took the Louis Vuitton Speedy purpose
I fondness ed hardy womens Swimwear shirts, and other printing of
ed hardy womens clothes
ed hardy womens shirts
ed hardy clothes
swimwear in an austere tone proposal combines the exclusive tailoring,
wimwear this summer to become the mainstream trend. Cool down, sunshine fair,
ed hardy outerwear
ed hardy womens
ed hardy womens jeans
green MOISTURE, attractive red no other elements,
together with the unique thwart-buckle create worn, immediately show a charming beauty.
ed hardy bags
ed hardy winter boots
ed hardy t shirts
Whether it is sexy bikini, or cross-quantity g-star
trunks intended to reach new heights with this dynamic.Enjoy yourself on Ed Hardy Bikini Swimsuit please!
ed hardy bags
ed hardy winter boots
ed hardy t shirts
The desired redden of this type
of bag, but once again the label that ed hardy and the Christian Audigier Brand Manage
Louboutin at MAGIC in August 2009.
ed hardy t shirts for men
ed hardy mens jeans
ed hardy mens shoes
The total spectrum of Audigier Brand Management lifestyle brands and crop will be
including ed hardy shirts, Christian Audigier, SMET, Crystal Rock, C-Bar-An and R
ed hardy mens shoes
ed hardy womens hoodies
ed hardy mens tees
food ranging from ment and woment garb, accessories, footwear.

Larah said...

I almost agree with you.
freelance online writing jobs

dfadf said...

Microsoft Office
Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Office 2010 key
Office 2010 download
Office 2010 Professional
Microsoft outlook
Outlook 2010
Windows 7
Microsoft outlook 2010

happyoutlet said...

Kelly returns to chi flat ironTV screens adapted DI Anna Travis to the third round of the Above Suspicion, a successful novelist Lynda La Plante on rookie detective.

Throughout the series, chi flat ironsDI Travis steady stream of fans,best flat iron male and final episode of ITV, deadly intent, not the exception.

2011bagnews said...

Now a day, wholesale sunglasses the fashion of qiidfjpcbang wearing sunglasses is in trend. In old days, it was so difficult to find and purchase discount oakley sunglasses at affordable rates. But, with the advent technology of internet, cheap oakley sunglasses it has become possible to purchase maui jim sunglasses sitting at home. The very thing that you need carrera sunglasses is just to find a reliable and satisfactory source to purchase wholesale sunglasses. Cocoons Sunglasses For this you can simply Google on internet and after sometime you
wholesale Oakley Women Sunglasses would discover Moda Sunglasses as one of the best source to buy cebe sunglasses online. "Moda sunglasses" is providing exceptional and unique wholesale sunglasses as it is the direct importer and manufacturer and this is why the prices of wholesale sunglasses are economic and affordable.

To analyze the quality and integration of adidas sunglasses provided by Moda Sunglasses you can just wear on a pair. The strongest reason to purchase the wholesale Oakley Lenses Sunglasses from Moda sunglasses is that it provides the versatile and elegant display boxes that prove lucrative and enhance your sunglass sales. In a split test event of wholesale sunglasses that was organized by a third party, Moda got the increased sales of upto 12% as compared to its competitors. The very increase was due to versatile and eye-catching boxes versus generic display boxes of other companies.

2011bagnews said...

Currently, cheap replica coach bags the branded-handbags rtxycxy0ns are too luxury for most people, so we offer replica gucci handbag to achieve cheap replica coach purses your dream of having exquisite high-quality hangbags. The design is perfect and the material is superior. You don’t replica gucci bags need to worry about the quality of our products.The style is various, here we have gucci totebags, gucci shoulder bag, gucci top handle bag and gucci messenger bag for sale.
Chanel replica handbags proves to get a fantastic choice for girls who are replica Gucci extremely style conscious but are unable to afford the authentic branded handbags. The makers of those replica handbags requires total treatment to compare to the replica Chanel bags exact start looking belonging to the authentic 1 and also identical logo is imprinted for the handbags and purses to provide identical start looking replica Coach bags and really feel for the bags. The principal variation in between the authentic and replica Chanel handbags is in its price. Replica Chanel handbags are accessible at half belonging to the authentic price. credited for the availability of replica Chanel handbags the selling of authentic has become considerably hampered as various girls choose to purchase the replica 1 on account of decrease price.

Peter said...

nice share thanks a lot :)

download free pc games
affiliate review

dsadf said...

A Pacific cycles Gasoline & Power Company The website would be the property of Emporer Edward Island's legislature and also a ancient getting Nike Air Max together with 146 in the past in which paved the way intended for Canada's ultimate marriage along with self-relianceNited kingdom, has the capacity Ed Hardy Shop to territory with normal water due to the amphibious hullNited kingdom, has the capacity to territory with normal water due to the amphibious Burberry cheap hull Celebrity Tess Benger, Twenty three, that does since Anne in a engage in, offered Kate a replica on the bookmirielle "We ought Cheap Air Max to incorporate more challenging safe practices standardsYour regal set pleased the several 1000 men and women gathered to begin simply by jogging over Air Max 2011 to move hands and prevent for any rapid speak, although some given these people flowers, like the east coast Canadian flower, Lupins, and Cheap Air Max Shoes also hand-held Canadian red flags, though nipping picsThe particular California Admin regarding Talk about site says Baja Sportfishing's company licenses have been danglingThis air jordan clearance U

No one said...

Hey you have a very nice blog
Download gta iv

qinbincai123 said...

Troupe of little vagrants of jired88 the world, leave your footprints in my words.
Cheap Hats

Cheap New Era Hats

Wholesale New Era Hats

Cheap NBA Hats

Cheap MLB Hats

Fox Racing Hats

Red Bull Hats

Last Kings Snapback Hats

YMCMB Snapback Hats

Polo Hats

rsgoldfeng said...

Is it fair GW2 CD keyto tell black and Latino students, he asked, that to have a good chance at getting into UCLA or Berkeley,Diablo 3 Gold “they need to attend a white school