Sunday, February 19, 2006

False rape charges: a feminist responds

Recently, Jeff Goldstein challenged feminist bloggers to respond to a bizarre California story about a false accusation of rape that was disproved only by the existence of a videotape, and to the fact that such charges -- which can potentially lead to years of imprisonment for the falsely accused -- are generally treated lightly by the legal system. I responded to the story here.

Now, Jill at Feministe -- one of the bloggers Jeff addressed -- has a response of her own. Jill points to an absolutely horrible story from Iran, involving a teenage girl named Naznin, who has been sentenced to death by hanging for stabbing a man to death when he and two other men tried to rape her and her niece in a park after chasing away their male companions by pelting them with stones.

Jill then comments:

There isn’t much else to say about this one, is there? It’s disgusting beyond words.

But of course, I shouldn’t take this girl’s word on its face. I mean, we all know that women lie about rape for fun and no one lies about other crimes, and this girl especially had something to gain. Perhaps we should consider a higher legal bar in evaluating rape charges. Right?

Of course, if a male blogger posted some terrible story about an innocent man being lynched on a false accusation of rape, and then added a snarky aside along the lines of, "I mean, we all know that women never lie about rape and we should just believe the women," then we'd all know he was a misogynist... right?

I've seen Jill's posts before, at Feministe and on others blogs. I've often disagreed with her, but she always struck me as someone willing, at least, to engage in an honest exchange of ideas. But now, confronted with an open-and-shut case of a woman lying about rape -- a lie that could have sent six men to prison for many years -- she can do no better than to use Nazanin's tragic story to try to score a cheap rhetorical point.

Disappointing, to say the least.


jw said...

Cathy: I've long thought that there is a quasi-religious faith based factor to "feminism." I'm not talking about the ordinary version here, rather the true believer.

There are a great many out there who believe so strongly in the tenets of the faith "feminism" that there is no possibility of discussion. It is like trying to talk about about Abrahamic religions with an uneducated bible-thumper ...

For too many people what-I-believe is set in stone: There is no possibility of a real answer to the question "why do I believe as I believe?"

My greatest problem with this is the number of people who take what a faith-based feminist says at face value; who believe because she/he said it. This spawns more problems.

Cathy Young said...

I like the "faith-based feminist" line, jw!

Anonymous said...

As a criminal defense lawyer I can tell you that while false accusations are probably rare, they certainly occur. Further, because most cases are settled by guilty pleas, as you would expect the proportion of false accusations is much greater for those few cases that actually go to trial. Therefore, I believe that each and every case must be considered based on its own facts. In criminal court--where the only question is what is going to happen to the defendant--our constitution properly requires juries to apply the standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. For other purposes, a less stringent standard of proof is and most certainly should be applied. The problem, as I see it, is that far too many people have ideological blinders on that prevent them from considering each case on its own merits.

mythago said...

A rhetorical point is "cheap" if you don't agree with it, you mean? I guess it's not "cheap" to assume that the legal system (every aspect of it) treats false accusations of crime "lightly" because the penalties for false reporting of any crime are not, in your opinion, high enough.

Jill's point was to show what happens in places that have very high legal standards for rape accusations.

EricP said...

BTW, Jill did indicate that conflating the two was done out of anger and offered to remove the text if Jeff wanted. He never said either way.

I read through all the comments at Feministe and I've rarely seen so much effort at arguing against what someone wrote by building strawmen (there were several separate efforts going on!).

Cathy Young said...

mythago: I think a rhetorical point is "cheap" if it uses an extreme situation, and an extreme leap of logic, to invalidate valid concerns about a problem.

Just because, in another culture, disbelief toward a woman's claim of rape has resulted in a horrible tragedy does not mean that there are no false charges of rape, or that an overly unskeptical attitude toward such charges cannot result in monstrous injustice as well.

Incidentally, in the case in Iran, the young woman's claim seemed to have ample corroboration -- I assume from her cousin and from the two young men who had been out walking wtih them. In any case, if we were talking about American legal standards, the young woman in this case should have been entitled to the benefit of the doubt, since she's the defendant.

EricP: Who's building strawmen, Jill or her commenters? (I haven't read the comments thread over there.) Personally, I think Jill ought to remove this comment regardless of what Jeff says or doesn't say, because it makes her look bad.

Synova said...

Is it possible to ignore individual justice and succeed in gaining victory over a larger injustice?

I had an interesting (but brief) exchange concerning the allegation that female Soldiers in Iraq are dying from dehydration because they don't dare go to the latrine at night for fear of being raped by male Soldiers. Pointing out factual errors in the charges was percieved as outright hostility toward women because even if *all* the facts were provably wrong, there *were* rape victims and questioning this truth was pretty much spitting on them.

Yeah, this is definately "faith based" feminism.

Truth matters. It's every bit as bad for the cause of justice to err on the side of believing charges without question as it is to dismiss them. And believing a lie doesn't serve a purpose for those "unknown" victims that must exist.

What I sometimes wonder... don't any of these people have SONS?

EricP said...

Who's building strawmen, Jill or her commenters?

It is the commenters. It is some of the regular posters who can be pretty smart in most cases but are going out of their way not to look at Jeff's point directly in this case. I don't think that this is an active decision, I just think that they have drunk so much of the coolaid that they can't see their own assumptions.

The Navigator said...

I think many feminists would note that women's reactions to sexual assault can vary, and that sometimes women who feel deeply threatened will act as if they are going along with an assault and even act as if they're enjoying it, in hopes of placating the attackers and avoiding the beating that might result if they resisted.

I'm not saying that happened in this case - wasn't there, haven't seen the tape, have no idea of the truth - but it doesn't seem all that implausible that a woman, finding herself surrounded by six men who were intent on having sex with her, would act in a way calculated to avoid being viciously assaulted.

Having said that, I'd think that feminists wouldn't have a problem with higher penalties for false accusations - after all, they don't think there are any false accusations, and, at least when it comes to rape trials, they appear to believe that people alleged to have committed a crime must always be convicted of that crime.

Richard Bennett said...

It never fails that whenever somebody tries to discuss an issue where men or boys are disadvantaged relative to women and girls that some so-called feminist with a chip on her shoulder gets all sarastic and tries to derail the discussion.

I used to joke that groups like Feminist Majority Fund argue that American women need lifetime alimony because of the Taliban, but it's not much of a joke anymore.

Back in the mid-90s we used to have pretty reasonable discussions about gender politics on Usenet and the e-mail lists, but nowadays the feminists are retreating to walled gardens, all the better to nurture their increasingly delusional doctrine of victimization.

Blogs like this one and Jeff's are a breath of fresh air.

mythago said...

Back in the mid-90s we used to have pretty reasonable discussions about gender politics on Usenet and the e-mail lists

This was in Bizarro-World mid-90s, right?

Anonymous said...

Cathy: I have been reading a lot about the issues you discuss in particular the mine field of "False Rape Accusation". The topic is sadly polarised and riddled with the misuse of statistics.

Your articles and the comments of the readers gives one of the very few quality spaces on the web I have found. I disagree with enough to realise I am not just reading to reinforce my opinions and agree with enough to feel this is a reasoned place. I shall be visiting again.


(ps. Gwyn is a male name in Europe which is where I am from)

Apa Saja Dah said...

Find and download what you need at Rapidshare Search Engine.
Top Site List Free Proxy Site Free Download mp3 Michael Jackson song All Michael Jackson Lirics Oes Tsetnoc Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa Download Mp3 Gratis

James Taylor said...

corporate logo design | animated logo | web design

James Taylor said...

label design | logo design service

nike said...

Rubber. Rubber is widly used in the outsole of the athletic shoes.
cheap puma shoes
discount puma shoes
It has the advantages of durable, skipproof, flexible, elastic, extensive, stable and proper hardness.
nike shox torch
nike tn dollar
cheap nike shox
PU is a kind of macromolecule polyurethane materials which is offten used in the midsole
cheap nike shox shoes
nike shox r4
puma mens shoes
Sometimes, it is also used in the outsole of casual shoes.
PU is durable, strong hardness, upstanding flexbility and more important, it is environmentally
cheap nike max
discount nike shox
cheap puma ferrari shoes
The disadvantage is also outstanding. Strong hydroscopic property, break apart and EVA.
nike mens shoes
ed hardy womens hoodies
ed hardy mens tees
You will never find swimsuit more excellent than in Ed Hardy!
ed hardy ugg boots
ed hardy love kills slowly boots
ed hardy love kills slowly
We provide you with the sexiest swimwear at present. Wanting to be bright on beach in this
ed hardy polo shirts
ed hardy love kills slowly shoes
ed hardy wear
Abandoning traditional concepts on sexy swimwear, Ed Hardy adds tattoo upon, which is meaning
ed hardy love kills slowly shirts
ed hardy trousers
ed hardy jackets
It seems that ed hardy mens shoes was difficult to be able to let you exist out in swimwear, the
ed hardy t shirts sale
ed hardy womens t shirts
ed hardy boots
In the trunks term, the Panerai candy-flush has mainly took the Louis Vuitton Speedy purpose
ed hardy womens clothes
ed hardy womens shirts
ed hardy clothes

Larah said...

I probably buy essay for this theme.

aiya said...

Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Microsoft word
Office 2007
Microsoft Office
Microsoft Office 2007
Office 2007 key
Office 2007 download
Office 2007 Professional
Outlook 2010
Microsoft outlook
Microsoft outlook 2010
Windows 7

GuestUser said...

Harga Mobil Bekas | Ramalan 2011 | Video Tante Girang | Foto Pernikahan Pasha dan Delia | Update Status Romantis | Tante Girang | No HP Tante Girang | Daftar Harga HP Bekas | Bug Pada Game Point Blank Online | Biro Jodoh Online | Ramalan Bintang | Ramalan Shio Zodiak Tionghoa | Point Blank Online Indonesia | Status Keren | Harga HP Android | Point Blank Online | Cara Daftar Point Blank Online | ucapan valentine 2011 | Makanan khas natal 2010 | Film terbaru 2011 | trend model gaya rambut 2011 | | Ramalan tahun kelinci 2011 | Car review | New Car Release | Blog berita terkini | Charlotte auto insurance | TV Online Indonesia | Mivo TV | Puppy Dog Food Store | Debby Ayu Bugill | Indonesia Vs Filipina | Juara Piala AFF Suzuki Cup 2010 | Kumpulan berita baru point blank Berita terbaru adidas online store

happyoutlet said...

Mortgage and mezzaninechi flat iron capital due to speak once in August, court records. SL Green Loan Services LLC of special services for the mortgage,chi flat irons according to the court filing.

more than in Chapter 11 petitions and lists CHI Ceramic Flat Irons of creditors at 15 December Little had been made. Nothing more was to appear on December 21, if the statements were posted on the court file with basic information about


Peter said...

nice share thanks a lot :)

download free pc games
affiliate review

Hair Transplant in turkey said...

Comments made ??about the issues impressed me. I like your site.
Fue Saç
Diş Doktoru