Friday, January 06, 2006

Everything you knew about Hurricane Katrina was wrong

We've heard it over and over again: Hurricane Katrina was not just a natural disaster, and not just a tragic case of government bungling, but a searing indictment of American racism and social injustice.

Apparently, this conventional wisdom is completely wrong.

Knight Ridder reports:

Four months after Hurricane Katrina, analyses of data suggest that some widely reported assumptions about the storm's victims were incorrect.

For example, a comparison of locations where 874 bodies were recovered with U.S. census tract data indicates that the victims weren't disproportionately poor. Another database of 486 Katrina victims from Orleans and St. Bernard parishes, compiled by Knight Ridder, suggests they also weren't disproportionately African American.

Both sets of data are incomplete; Louisiana state officials have released no comprehensive list of the dead. Still, they provide the most comprehensive information available to date about who paid the ultimate price in the storm.

The one group that was disproportionately affected by the storm appears to have been older adults. People 60 and older account for only about 15 percent of the population in the New Orleans area, but the Knight Ridder database found that 74 percent of the dead were 60 or older. Nearly half were older than 75. Many of those were at nursing homes and hospitals, where nearly 20 percent of the victims were recovered.

Lack of transportation was assumed to be a key reason that many people stayed behind and died, but at many addresses where the dead were found, their cars remained in their driveways, flood-ruined symbols of fatal miscalculation.

The addresses where bodies were recovered were compiled by Louisiana state officials and released earlier this month. Knight Ridder charted the locations on a map of Orleans and St. Bernard parishes, then compared them with census data on income in those neighborhoods. The analysis excluded 216 bodies that were recovered from hospitals and nursing homes, as well as 63 recovered at collection points where people had dropped off bodies in the days after the storm ...

The comparison showed that 42 percent of the bodies found in Orleans and St. Bernard parishes were recovered in neighborhoods with poverty rates higher than 30 percent. That's only slightly higher than the 39 percent of residents who lived in such neighborhoods, according to the census data.

Similarly, 31 percent of the bodies turned up in areas with poverty rates below 15 percent, where 30 percent of the population lived.

The median household income in neighborhoods where Katrina victims were recovered was about $27,000 a year, just under the $29,000 median for the overall area.

One-fourth of Katrina deaths fell in census tracts with median incomes above $35,300. One-fourth of the area's pre-storm population lived in tracts with median incomes above $37,000.

About 67 percent of the mapped deaths fell in the central and western portion of New Orleans, an area thought to have flooded primarily because of the failure of man-made structures.

The separate Knight Ridder database of 486 Katrina victims was compiled from official information released by state and federal authorities and interviews with survivors of the dead. It catalogued deaths according to location, race, age, name and cause of death.

In that database, African Americans outnumbered whites 51 percent to 44 percent. In the area overall, African Americans outnumber whites 61 percent to 36 percent.

In Orleans Parish, 62 percent of known Katrina victims were African American, compared with 66 percent for the total parish population.

In St. Bernard Parish, 92 percent of the identified victims were white. Census figures show that 88 percent of parish residents identified themselves as white.

Among hurricane victims on the Knight Ridder list, men outnumbered women 51 percent to 49 percent, about the same as in the overall area before the storm.

(Hat tip: Eric at Classical Values.)

Of course, deaths are not the only measure of Katrina's impact. It may well be, for instance, that the people left dispossessed by the hurricane are disproportionately poor and/or black; it is very likely that people with few resources will find recovery more diffcult. But Katrina's dead were certainly the starkest evidence of the hurricane's devastating impact; and we were told that those dead had been killed by racism and economic injustice, by societal and political indifference to the plight of black people and poor people. So the Knight Ridder investigation does, in fact, seem to knock down Katrina's central myth.

Eric inquires:

Is it reasonable to expect apologies from the people who claimed that the deaths were a form of "genocide" caused by Bush racism?
Reasonable, yes; realistic, no.

Meanwhile, GayPatriot.com suggests one obvious conclusion: "George Bush hates old people!"

On a more serious note: the paucity of coverage this story has received is disappointing, and rather remarkable. The article was released by Knight Ridder on December 30 and picked up by 22 Knight-Ridder newspaper, but few featured it very prominently. Only three -- The Charlotte Observer, The Akron Beacon Journal, and The Bradenton Herald (Florida) -- ran it on the front page; most buried it well inside. The analysis has received no mention in The New York Times, The Washington Post, or USA Today; there has not been a single editorial commenting on it, from any of the papers that told us all about how Katrina has exposed the inequities of race and class in America.

No wonder a lot of people think there really is a "liberal media."

Rather surprisingly, the blogosphere has also paid little attention to this debunking of Katrina myths. Yet this is an important story which says a great deal about the knee-jerk acceptance of claims that support conventional wisdom about America's social ills. It should be reported more widely, and there should be more apologies.

109 comments:

Anonymous said...

An old adage applies to some of the outrageous statements made by some people in the wake of the Katrina tragedy. " Don't assume,because assuming can make an ass out of you and me ."

Anonymous said...

Death is certainly not the only variable in determining impact. There were few white faces in those crowds of thousands left behind and at risk of death due to the governments poor reponse.
Cars don't tell much either. Were they any good? Could people afford gas, food and hotels if they left?

And there are still 3000 missing. LA officials admit some were certainly washed out to sea.
And they are still recovering bodies from the 9th Ward.

Death doesn't nearly tell the story.

Anonymous said...

Interesting, thank you.

Anonymous said...

Well, there's no accounting for that liberal blogosphere. They're all too busy kissing up to the Hollywood Elite and going to Georgetown cocktail parties.

Seriously, KN should get more attention. They were the only major outlet doing serious reporting on the run-up to the Iraq war (and were cut out of the daily gaggle because of it). I do rather like them.

Cathy Young said...

What's KN?

Cathy Young said...

Oh -- d'uh! Knight Ridder! I thought you were referring to a blog. *feels dumb*

Anonymous said...

Sorry, I should have abbreviated "KR" - I was referring to Knight Ridder in the above post.

Anonymous said...

No reason to feel dumb... I'm the idiot that misdirected.

--me, who once again vows to stop using shorthand when conversing with others. At least until I start again.

Anonymous said...

It's still disgusting no matter how you try to rationalize it or look at it. The function of govt is to protect society's most vulnerable members, a group the majority of elderly can be placed in.

Anonymous said...

"The function of govt is to protect society's most vulnerable members"

Where does it say that in the Constitution?

Noah Boddie said...

I am still in shock at what a free ride the Governor and Mayor are still getting from the press. Why the President had to call the governor (interrupting her dinner) to finally beg her to order an evacuation, and why the Mayor then waited another half a day, is a question they have never had to answer to.

I said to myself when I saw those lines of people in the rain, waiting to get into the Superdome, "that's a deathtrap."

I blame the "Bush is not my President" attitude of the local authorities for their failure to allow a Fed takeover of the situation until it was way too late. And for them to try to turn that around and blame Bush sickens me to this day.

So why do they continue to avoid even the slightest ounce of culpability? They're too busy going back to stealing and misusing all the billions being poured back into their bottomless coinjar.

Anonymous said...

This story has been done by the AP, the NYT, the Washington Post, the New Orleans Times-Picayne, the Los Angeles Times, etc. etc.

The media has done a lot of data aanlyses similar to the Knight-Ridder story you quote.

It's hilarious to say, as you do, that this story has been underplayed or minimized. It has, I guess, if you haven't been paying any attention.

Dexter Westbrook

Anonymous said...

Actually, I remember Rush Limbaugh, of all people, talking about this story last month, and I hardly ever listen to that guy. Somebody who has access to his paid archives could probably confirm.

DADvocate said...

Michelle Malkin touched on this about a month ago.

Helaine inadvertently points out the lefts' real motives, finding ways to blame government, especially the Federal (Bush) government. They continue to largely ignore the failures of the local and state governments as well as the individuals responsibility (freedom) to leave or stay in the face of impending disaster.

Jeff said...

What happened to "it takes a village?"

I dispute Helaine's statement, "The function of govt is to protect society's most vulnerable members."

The Federal government arguably can rightly be invested with responsibilities for safety and security, and for over 200 years, citizens and the representatives they elect have done just that.

But these responsibilities can only be sustainable by viewing such vestment in a broader hierarchy of responsibility.

Who is most responsible for the elderly, their care, safety, security and wellbeing?

I would argue the following order of responsibility, in order of diminishing degree of responsibility:
1. individual who will grow elderly, and rightly makes choices (as best they can) to save, prepare, maintain health, create and preserve support systems, maintain family and community relationships, etc.
2. immediate and extended families of elderly, same tasks as above.
3. local communities (government, church, community groups), to maintain visibility of support organizations and services, to foster self-help for families, to maintain vigilance in identifying those elderly with limited family support or means, in providing basic local services.
4. State government, to maintain visibility of support organizations and services, to foster self-help for communities, to maintain vigilance in identifying those local communities with limited support or means and assist them in providing basic local services. Additionallly, provide those state level resources that would not feasibly be available to or provided by local communities.
5. Federal government, to maintain visibility of support organizations and services, to foster self-help for states, to maintain vigilance in identifying those states with limited support or means and assist them in providing support to local communities. Additionallly, provide those national level resources that would not feasibly be available to or provided by local communities or state governments.

Color me naive, but there are many boatloads of responsibilities before you get to the Federal level in my view. Odd that in the case of both flooding in Louisiana and heat in France, the elderly are disproportionately affected? Could it be that NO and LA populations share some similar assumptions as the French? (About social welfare, personal responsibilities, abandonment of the elderly).

Just a thought.

Anonymous said...

Helaine said...
It's still disgusting no matter how you try to rationalize it or look at it. The function of govt is to protect society's most vulnerable members, a group the majority of elderly can be placed in.


It was the job of local government to have an evacuation plan, and to put that plan into effect. That's a part of the FEMA regs. A state or municipality can't qualify for FEMA assistance without such a plan. So, again, why did the local government fail to act on their plan, and why does Ray Nagin continue to get a free pass from the MSM?

Nevermind. I think I know the answer.

Anonymous said...

I just hope that out here in California, the fifth (or sixth) richest country in the world, the State Legislature is setting aside 5 billion dollars a year for our next earthquake. They are mostly Democrats so we know they are working together on the really important issues.

Charlie Martin said...

It's still disgusting no matter how you try to rationalize it or look at it. The function of govt is to protect society's most vulnerable members, a group the majority of elderly can be placed in.

I don't think Cathy's saying it's good: just that most of the explanations --- and the imputed motives --- are wrong.

Anonymous said...

"I just hope that out here in California, the fifth (or sixth) richest country in the world, the State Legislature is setting aside 5 billion dollars a year for our next earthquake. They are mostly Democrats so we know they are working together on the really important issues."

If they do wash out to sea it will be because of the inept politicians Californians accepted as their rightful governers when they rejected the referendum proposal to have legislator districts determined by an independant panel. Californians made the most explicit statement possible that they did not want a voice in their government and so they deserve what they have, the worst government west of Louisiana.

Anonymous said...

There was an evacuation plan, it was employed, and the majority of residents of Orleans and Jefferson Parish successfully evacuated. What most people miss in this story is that the elderly folks who did not leave refused to leave. There are a number of factors involved, the two most important being a sense of security in one's home, and the local history of people riding out hurricanes.

To me the story was not that Katrina did not disproportionately affect black folks; what the MSM is not covering is that most of the people who stayed chose to stay for one reason or another.

There is no evacuation plan in existence that could have taken people out of the City in significantly greater numbers than actually occurred. You cannot forcibly remove people, and a lot of people who now claim they would have left had buses been provided are lying. The horrific scenes in the Superdome and Convention Center occurred long after the flooding made it impossible to leave via car or bus; prior to those conditions existing - i.e. prior to the flooding, people who chose to stay would not have left.

Cathy said that the blogosphere is not covering this issue. Local blogs here in New Orleans certainly are, and our local paper is as well. I know that's irrelevant to the point she was trying to make, but I thought I'd point it out anyway.

Finally, people keep calling out Ray Nagin; he's the best mayor we've had in the city in my lifetime, and I'm a fairly conservative guy. He did not have a particularly Giuliani experience with/re: Katrina, but I still have a great deal of respect for him and for how he handles a very difficult job.

Anonymous said...

going back to the top comments...
"And there are still 3000 missing. LA officials admit some were certainly washed out to sea.
And they are still recovering bodies from the 9th Ward."

Are there really still 3000 missing. I'll take your word for it, but do you have a link?

Anonymous said...

How can anyone rationally argue that 3,000 people or anywhere near that number were "washed out to sea"? What an amazingly non-credible attempt to support a "preconceived belief." Where are the bodies washing back onto shore? Where are the bodies popping up in the gulf and being found by boaters?

We now know the levees were not topped. They collapsed and the water flowed in! Water flowing in does not wash bodies out. If you want to hold to a belief, hold to one that you can at least try to support with facts.

LonewackoDotCom said...

The horrific scenes in the Superdome and Convention Center occurred long after the flooding made it impossible to leave via car or bus

I believe they were able to do an evac of Algiers with buses after the flooding, and there was an open route between that bus barn and the Superdome. See the post about Algiers here.

Search for 'missing' at that site for a couple entries. Search for 'mortician' for yet more unanswered questions.

Anonymous said...

I've been skeptical of media coverage of natural disasters since our last big earthquake in Seattle - around 5 years ago.

It was a 7 point something earthquake - pretty much an "event" for those of us in the city. However, there was very little damage (at least of the dramatic, obvious kind). The damage that did occur was in Pioneer Square - an area with the greatest concentration of older buildings. One or two buildings were significantly damaged, providing a good photo op. The photos of these buildings were the ones most frequently used in newspapers and other media vehicles throughout the US.

As a result, I got many frantic emails and phone calls from friends and family, hysterical, and wanting to know if I was ok. "My God", all of them said, "the city looks horrible."

I never trusted the media in terms of this kind of coverage again. I'm convinced that any natural disaster brings out the drama queen in all journalists.

Beth said...

It's true that the dead are mainly old, and white. But they're only one measure of the storm, and the fact remains that most of what Bush promised in his nationally televised speech from Jackson Square has yet to happen. One commenter here lambasts our governor and mayor for having a "Bush is not our President" attitude; that person is clearly ignorant of our local politics. The mayor, Nagin, changed parties from GOP to Democrat when he ran for local office, and endorsed Republican Bobby Jindal over Blanco in the governor's race. Nor is that post's summation of the evacuation timeline correct. But please, blather on as if you know something. Pulling out the "They just hate Bush!" meme seems to work well for some conservatives; it makes all that actual thinking unnecessary.

Meanwhile, Mississippi, with a GOP governor and U.S. congressional reps and Senators, is receiving more aid, and faster, than Louisiana is. The two states are receiving the same amount of aid to restore their colleges and universities, for example, but Mississippi's system didn't sustain even a 1/4 of the damage that ours did. You'd have to be a deranged Bush hater to find anything partisan in that, though, right?

There are indeed close to 3000 people missing; if you want to keep up with that figure, check nola.com once a week or so for the New Orleans Times-Picayune's reports. It's presumed at least some of those simply have not contacted anyone after evacuating. The current Katrina death toll (for the entire affected region) topped 1300 this week.

As for buses in the Westbank town of Algiers, the failure to use those will be Nagin's biggest sin during the leadup to the storm. But after the storm, armed police from Gretna, a town across the river, blocked New Orleans evacuees--a large group composed mainly of black people--from crossing the bridge, the "open route" that Lonewhacko mentions. The Gretna police were afraid of looters, and a big group of blacks must be looters; what else? Our state attorney general is investigating that action.

Meanwhile, the other racial issues currently in play are over Mardi Gras (some see it as a big party for white people--they ignore the crucial economics at stake), and bulldozing of houses. The houses the city wants to bulldoze immediately are all in the 9th Ward, a nearly all-black neighborhood utterly destroyed by the flood waters. Finally, race will be a heated issue as plans for rebuilding become finalized. It's almost certain that the people unable to rebuild largely be black, lower middle class to poor, who owned homes in the city's 9th Ward. White homeowners in parts of Lakeview are also going to be discouraged from rebuilding. The question is one of geography--what can we protect from future floodwaters? But the outcome of that decision will disproportionately affect black people.

The essay is right; the death count demographics do expose one myth of racism. But there's much more to learn from the aftermath of Katrina.

Anonymous said...

Robert: Finally, people keep calling out Ray Nagin; he's the best mayor we've had in the city in my lifetime, and I'm a fairly conservative guy. He did not have a particularly Giuliani experience with/re: Katrina, but I still have a great deal of respect for him and for how he handles a very difficult job.

I have to agree. The flurry of talking points that started circulating immediately ("local problem", "dumb democrat mayor", "if they were too dumb to leave..", etc. completely ignore reality for the most part, but it is especially funny WRT Nagin. He's really quite remarkably good.

Elizabeth: Pulling out the "They just hate Bush!" meme seems to work well for some conservatives; it makes all that actual thinking unnecessary.

Shhh... the highly partisan types go feral if you let them know you're on to them.

Anonymous said...

I didn't mean to post and leave everyone hanging. Life, as it does, intervened and I've just signed back on.

A few points. There's lots of blame to go around on Hurricane Katrina. The federal govt. The state govt. The city and parrish govts. The families of people who got trapped. Bad decisions made by many of the elderly themselves. Etc. But one does not excuse the other. For example, I lived in So. Cal for years. If there is a fire and you are in an evacuation zone, the authorities will make a determined effort to force you out.

And, yes, it is a primary duty of govt. to protect citizens when they are vulnerable. I won't back down on this. In this specific case, not everyone had a family loving enough or savvy enough to come and get them out of their house. And some people do make bad decisions. But they don't deserve to die because of that.

Revenant said...

Meanwhile, Mississippi, with a GOP governor and U.S. congressional reps and Senators, is receiving more aid, and faster, than Louisiana is.

Heh. Didn't bother looking up what parties Louisiana's politicians belong to, eh?

Mississippi's Congressional delegation contains 4 Republicans and 2 Democrats. Louisiana's contains 6 Republicans and 3 Democrats. So not only are both state's Congressional delegations equally Republican, but Louisiana has more of them -- in fact, Louisiana has more Republican Representatives than Mississippi has *total* Representatives.

You'd have to be a deranged Bush hater to find anything partisan in that, though, right?

Yes, you would have to be a deranged Bush hater to believe that Republicans screwed over a larger Republican state in favor of a smaller Republican state for "partisan reasons". What, were they supposedly bitter because only 57% of Louisiana voted for Bush in 2004, compared to 60% of Mississippi? Or, wait -- did they decide that since their non-white candidate lost to the white Democratic candidate 48-52, the best way to win the next election was to make the whole Louisiana electorate mad at Republicans by sending "their" relief money to Mississippi?

The truth, of course, is that both states are getting every penny they deserve and billions they don't. Mississippi has been more successful in picking the other 48 states' pockets because Mississippi's Republican congresscritters are more influential than Louisiana's Republican congresscritters. There's no deeper reason than that.

Anonymous said...

Whatever happened to personal responsibility in this country?

This is why libertarianism is on life support.

People could have:

1. Not lived in a city below sea level with an artifical system in place to keep the whole two nfrom being underwater.

2. Lived in the city but made sure to live in an area less susceptible to floods.

3. Not invested in real estate that had a decent chance to be ruined by a flood. They could have rented instead.

4. Got their asses the hell out of the city when the hurricaine announcements were coming.

5. Living in a coastal area prone to hurricaines, they could have been already prepared with supplies and escape routes and such should the worst happen.

6. Even ignoring all of the above, not be a jackass pimple on the backside of humanity and engage in looting, violence and other lawless behavior just because they could.

Anyone who couldn't accomplish any of the above have as much responsibility for the bad things that happened as any government official, Republican or Democrat, federal, state, city or parish.

I don't understand people. Sometimes they complain that government tries to be like police state and control their lives. And then other times these same people beg them to do exactly that.

Anonymous said...

Wow. Here was a city which was run by one political party literally for decades without the dissent of evil, selfish, racist reactonaries. I mean, it should have been heaven on earth. The best education, the lowest crime, no corruption, the cleanest air and water, "free" on demand medical care, freedom from fear, from want, state of the art infrastructure and emergency services, the list goes on and on. That it was a social and economic basket case even before Katrina seems to be lost on some of us. And where are the "compassionate defenders of the little guy" now that the policies supporting their world view have again been proven murderously wrong. Averting their gaze and continuing their narrative about how its (always) someone else's fault.

Anonymous said...

-- The attention span of the nation and of the MSM has apparently been exhausted by Katrina/Rita, and whatever lessons might now be learned are being ignored. Nola.com needs to reorganize itself around the general topics: the list of dead, where the evacuees wound up & what they want to do, what needs to be bulldozed away, what needs to be preserved, how to supply temporary housing, what to do about MRGO, what to do about the other levees, etc. Both the internet and the MSM have become much less useful in following this story than than either were in September. If there is a blog focussed on tracking these issues, I haven't found it.
--- Not everything I knew about Katrina was wrong. It has been, was at the time, and still is, very foolish to reside below sea level. Nederlanders may be an exception.

Beth said...

Revenant, it's my state, I don't have to look it up. But your figures ignore the seniority of our GOP congress and Senate members, and the fact that our governor is a Democrat, as are our ranking Senator and many of our congressmen. Nor do I accuse Mississippi's delegation of "screwing" Louisiana, as you put it. In fact, our governor has publicly thanked their senior congressional for help in getting anything. The fact is that GOP leadership is getting a better response from the feds. In a time of crisis, that's a damn shame.

Your assertion that we're getting every penny we deserve is just your opinion. Back it up. You haven't a clue.

Beth said...

Anonymous offers:

People could have:

1. Not lived in a city below sea level with an artifical system in place to keep the whole two nfrom being underwater.

I expect we'll be depopulating North Texas and Oklahoma any day now. It's dry there, and stuff burns!

2. Lived in the city but made sure to live in an area less susceptible to floods.

Part of the city that flooded is nowhere near any source of water. The levee and canal system failed.

3. Not invested in real estate that had a decent chance to be ruined by a flood. They could have rented instead.

Rented property owned by people who invested in real estate, right? You're going in circles here!

4. Got their asses the hell out of the city when the hurricaine announcements were coming.

About a million people did evacuate, Einstein. What else have you got?

5. Living in a coastal area prone to hurricaines, they could have been already prepared with supplies and escape routes and such should the worst happen.

See above. That doesn't save their homes, of course, or their businesses.

6. Even ignoring all of the above, not be a jackass pimple on the backside of humanity and engage in looting, violence and other lawless behavior just because they could.

Very little of this occured, so what exactly are you complaining about? Much of the looting was for food, water, and dry clothes. By far, people behaved well, and with each other's welfare in mind.

Revenant said...

Revenant, it's my state, I don't have to look it up.

So you were deliberately dishonest when you tried to make it sound like Louisiana wasn't a Republican state?

But your figures ignore the seniority of our GOP congress

I did not ignore seniority -- I cited the greater influence of the MS Republicans over the LA Republicans. But you tried to claim that partisanship was to blame, not about the seniority system. The Congressional preference for senior Republicans over junior Republicans isn't "partisanship"; "partisan" refers to interactions between *different* parties.

and Senate members, and the fact that our governor is a Democrat

Your governor is a Democrat because the GOP ran Piyush Jindal against a white person in one of the most racist states in America -- and he still only lost 48-52. Besides, the governor doesn't get to vote in Congress, so it doesn't matter which state has a Democratic governor.

as are our ranking Senator and many of our congressmen.

I did not ignore that. You have one Republican Senator, one Democratic senator, five Republican Representatives, and two (NOT "many") Democratic Representatives. Mississippi has two Republican Senators, two Republican Reps, and two Democratic reps.

Nor do I accuse Mississippi's delegation of "screwing" Louisiana, as you put it.

You accused Republicans of routing money Louisiana deserved and giving it to Mississippi for partisan reasons. If you want to play semantic games over whether that counts as "screwing", go ahead.

In fact, our governor has publicly thanked their senior congressional for help in getting anything. The fact is that GOP leadership is getting a better response from the feds.

The fact is that both Mississippi and Louisiana are hardcore Republican states these days. Ergo your claim that Louisiana was getting shortchanged because of partisanship is ridiculous. Now you want to change your argument and pretend you were talking about seniority instead of partisanship -- hey, go right ahead. MS is indeed, as I already observed, getting more than LA because of the greater influence of MS's congressmen. It is not, as you said, getting more because MS has Republican congressmen.

So yes, only a deranged Bush hater would blame partisanship for your failure to get all the pork you want. You live in what is, today, as solidly Republican a state as Texas and Mississippi. If Congress gyps you out of something it isn't because of partisan considerations.

Revenant said...

Your assertion that we're getting every penny we deserve is just your opinion.

Obviously any statement about how much aid money someone deserves is going to be "just opinion", since it is only a matter of opinion that anyone deserves any aid money at all. But the idea that my money should go to some twit who decided to live below sea level, so he can go BACK to living below sea level, is absurd to me. To the best of my knowledge New Orleans is in fact getting aid for the below-sea-level portions of the city, so there you have it -- more aid money than they deserve.

Plus, of course, even in a non-Katrina year LA gets more government largesse than it pays for with taxes. Democrats used to complain about this fact, actually, since Louisiana was one of the solidly-red states that solidly-blue states like California end up bankrolling. It takes a lot of arrogance for a state that was already getting bags of free money each year to demand even bigger bags of free money.

Anonymous said...

As a scientist I always had to guard against getting the results I wanted from an experiment and immediately concluding my hypotheses were correct without repeating the experiment and carefully examining everything. Always question, question ... (hear that Judy Miller). So much we heard was wrong etc. unfortunately the mass media is so caught up in rapidly broadcasting -- that this will continue. Thank goodness for the blogsphere, where someone will say wait-a-minute, for example the CBS fiasco on Bush and the Air Force in which documents prepared with Word.

Beth said...

Revenant, you are being deliberately obtuse. Louisiana is not a Republican state, and I have never said it was. Our senior and ranking officials are Democrats. Our GOP senator and congressmen don't have the juice to get much done. Mississippi's governor is the former head of the GOP, and their GOP lawmakers have held top positions in Congress. They are getting faster, and more substantial aid from the administration, and from Congress. You bet that's partisan.

Anonymous said...

I'm sorry; I replied to you before reading the rest of your comments fully. I wasn't aware of what an idiot you are. I'm done trying to deal in substance with a nitwit.

When you have no point to make, insults are always nice, right?

ANY money you are given from the gov't is more money than you are owed. You don't deserve any. Anything given is a GIFT.

Elizabeth, Louisiana is an overwhelmingly Republican state. New Orleans specifically is overwhelmingly Democratic, but Louisiana as a whole is very Republican.

You have a governor who couldn't successfully manage a bowel movement, much less a state gov't. You cannot blame anybody else because she is so utterly incompetent.
-=Mike

Revenant said...

Revenant, you are being deliberately obtuse. Louisiana is not a Republican state, and I have never said it was.

You should pay closer attention, because I never said you thought Louisiana was a Republican state -- I was criticizing you for making the bizarre claim that it *wasn't* a Republican state, a claim which you just made again. Louisiana's Congressional delegation is as solidly Republican as that of Texas and Mississippi and it enthusiastically supported Bush in 2000 and 2004. Sure, the local government contains a lot of DINOs, but the local government isn't what appropriates money from Congress.

Our GOP senator and congressmen don't have the juice to get much done.

So what? You claimed the reason they didn't get money was *partisanship*, not a lack of political mojo. One Republican taking money another Republican wants isn't partisanship.

You bet that's partisan.

Only if you're ignorant of what the term "partisan" means.

Anonymous said...

If your information is accurate and credible, it still doesn't really matter.

What was seen on the media cannot account for the facts that came out later. I don't think anyone was saying, "George Bush and Co. is poring over the recorded racial/age/class data for each area that was hit by Katrina and not being a good leader because they are poor and black."

They were saying, "look on the television, it's mostly poor black people stranded in New Orleans and if we were watching it with the difference being rich, white people, action would have been more speedy and efficient."

Anonymous said...

tyree said...
I just hope that out here in California, the fifth (or sixth) richest country in the world, the State Legislature is setting aside 5 billion dollars a year for our next earthquake. They are mostly Democrats so we know they are working together on the really important issues.


Or we can sit around, after the fact, saying that you should have known better than to reside in an area where earthquake insurance is key.

You know...like how they said those people should know better than to live in area that's below sea level.

It works both ways, eh?

Cathy Young said...

About the 3000 or so still missing, is there any reason to believe that the racial and class background among them would be different to the recorded deaths?

As for the majority of the refugees seen on TV being black: could that have something to do with the fact that that cameras focused predominantly on NO, and not on other affected areas?

Helaine, I certainly agree that the government has a responsibility to protect people from harm -- it's one of the functions of government that even most libertarian would recognize. And there certainly was a failure of government at all levels. My point, though, is that this does not seem to have been a tragedy of "racism and classism" as we were initially led to believe.

And by the way, while I agree there were failure of individual responsibility as well, and while I don't want to be the sensitivity police, some of the attitudes voiced here toward Katrina survivors are a bit... jarring.

Anonymous said...

I think that Louisiana's reputation for corruption, and revelations of the kind of ratholes previous levee money was poured down, have more to do with NO's problems than anything else.

I have been through several hurricanes, including one which included intense flooding, my home was covered in mud and some kind of oil to nearly the second floor in Agnes in '72. This "shocked, shocked.." attitude toward people who question bellyaching at us for money while at the same time accusing us of racism, is well, not working for you.

It's been said a lot because it contains a lot of wisdom. Get a job!

Anonymous said...

What was seen on the media cannot account for the facts that came out later. I don't think anyone was saying, "George Bush and Co. is poring over the recorded racial/age/class data for each area that was hit by Katrina and not being a good leader because they are poor and black."

They were saying, "look on the television, it's mostly poor black people stranded in New Orleans and if we were watching it with the difference being rich, white people, action would have been more speedy and efficient."


If the pictures broadcast do not reflect the reality of the situation, then the pictures are irrelevant and were cherry-picked for maximum political impact.

And the last sentence of your post is insane, since the statistics of those impacted clearly disprove your entire notion.
-=Mike

Revenant said...

Or we can sit around, after the fact, saying that you should have known better than to reside in an area where earthquake insurance is key. You know...like how they said those people should know better than to live in area that's below sea level. It works both ways, eh?

There are two problems with your argument. The first is that I live in southern California, and it IS an earthquake zone -- so I bought earthquake insurance! If I had refused to do so, and then an earthquake knocked my house down, I like to think I wouldn't have the nerve to insist that I was entitled to have my house rebuilt for me anyway. Granted, a lot of the people in New Orleans lived in areas insurance companies wouldn't cover... because they were guaranteed to flood. But it is hard to see why a person is entitled to benefits because they lived in an area that was SO foolish to live in that no insurance firm would touch them with a 10-foot pole.

The second point is a little more controversial. Basically, it is that Californians pay many billions of dollars per year more in taxes than we receive from the federal government, and have for many years. So a good argument could be made that, unlike Louisiana and Mississippi (which regularly receive more than they pay), we're *owed* a lot of benefits.

Beth said...

A lot of the places that flooded in New Orleans were not required to have flood insurance, because they were considerd, by insurance companies using flood maps, as not likely to flood, being on high ground. The storm did not flood anything; the canal and levee failures did that. That created a complex insurance situation. Some people had wind and weather coverage, but the flood isn't covered by that, since it wasn't the storm that caused it.

Louisiana and Mississippi provide oil royalties to the federal government. Saying the states take more than they give is correct only if you're looking at tax revenue. When you include the oil revenue--which neither state gets back in adequate amounts--that is no longer true. Both states would like to use more of their oil royalties for wetland restoration (which is directly related to oil production) and flood protection.

Beth said...

Cathy,

Another measure of the storm's affect is flooding. Today's New Orleans Times-Picayune reports: "That Katrina's floodwaters affected black residents more severely than white residents is a matter of statistical fact. Using flood maps and block-by-block data from the 2000 census, city consultant Greg Rigamer estimates that about half of the city's white citizenry experienced minimal or no flooding. By comparison, fewer than a quarter of black New Orleanians were so lucky."

The problem is, of course, that this fact of geography and nature is being used to fan the idea of a conspiracy to depopulate the city of its black residents. Racism did not cause this flooding pattern, but the fear, not entirely unfounded, is that racism will shape our response to it.

Anonymous said...

If the pictures broadcast do not reflect the reality of the situation, then the pictures are irrelevant and were cherry-picked for maximum political impact.

Wrong. No picture was irrelevant because there was truth in every, regardless of which pictures were "cherry picked." To believe in that notion is to believe that the people in the pictures were irrelevant. Besides, nothing you said negated what I said.

And the last sentence of your post is insane, since the statistics of those impacted clearly disprove your entire notion.

And...what? When were those statistics made public? After the fact? Yes. So, again, you're not negating anything I said.

Anonymous said...

There are two problems with your argument. The first is that I live in southern California, and it IS an earthquake zone -- so I bought earthquake insurance! If I had refused to do so, and then an earthquake knocked my house down, I like to think I wouldn't have the nerve to insist that I was entitled to have my house rebuilt for me anyway. Granted, a lot of the people in New Orleans lived in areas insurance companies wouldn't cover... because they were guaranteed to flood. But it is hard to see why a person is entitled to benefits because they lived in an area that was SO foolish to live in that no insurance firm would touch them with a 10-foot pole.

Everyone would like to think a lot of things about situations they haven't encountered...the question is will your opinion hold true to the reality? Debatable.

The second point is a little more controversial. Basically, it is that Californians pay many billions of dollars per year more in taxes than we receive from the federal government, and have for many years. So a good argument could be made that, unlike Louisiana and Mississippi (which regularly receive more than they pay), we're *owed* a lot of benefits.

There's a reason why your state pays more taxes. California is owed nothing less and nothing more than any other state.

Anonymous said...

People still aren't getting it.

Living in places below sea level or hurricaine alley or earthquake zones are choices people make. They are free to make these choices, but with those choices comes responsibility for the consequences of those choices.

But we don't like consequences. We want our lives to be consequence free, so that when the forseeable or the unforseeable happens and we're unprepared, it immediately becomes somebody else's fault, not ours.

Expecting the government to defend you from an invasion by the Russians is fine. Expecting the government to step by step remove you from the path of a hurricane at the government's expense is the height of socialist largesse.

Uncle Sam is not your rich uncle who sends you blank checks and a limo to cart you to and from the store, and this entitlement mentaility that has gripped most of the population is just infuriating.

The events that happened in New Orleans were forseeable (hurricane, levee failure, flooding, etc.) and a risk to living in that area. So the big bad happened and people suffered. My sympathies are sincere. But governments don't make hurricanes and they sure as hell were crystal clear about the dangers this one might bring.

That whatever branch of government didn't succeed in miracling up some theoretical happy fun place for everyone to ride out the damage without anyone suffering is a testament to just how dependent on government we've become.

And when the earthquakes hit California or the blizzards hit Minnesota, I'll sing the same tune.

Anonymous said...

"And by the way, while I agree there were failure of individual responsibility as well, and while I don't want to be the sensitivity police, some of the attitudes voiced here toward Katrina survivors are a bit... jarring."

I have sympathy for the survivors (which is a loaded term since in this case "survivors" means 99% of the population), but my sympathy extends only as far as the bounds of emotion are appropriate.

They sure as hell don't extend past the more rational areas of what actions are and are not appropriate for the government of a free people to take.

You can't just bail out everybody who runs through a streak of tough luck. Where does it end? Exactly how are we supposed to draw lines here? When 100 people die in Chicago of a heat wave, does the government then buy air-conditioners for the whole country? Does the government become the main supplier of snow chains in the northern states and the Rocky Mountains? When Barbars Streisands California home slides off the side of a mountain during a rainstorm, does Uncle Sam buy her a new home? If not because she's already got money, what income levels do we set as to whose home gets rebuilt or not? If a kid in a public park next door hits a baseball through my window, do I send the bill for the window to Uncle Sam.

Where does all this end if not everybody waiting in line for toilet paper?

The outpouring of private charity to the victims of the hurricane is heartening and reassuring. But our government has a responsibility to not express it's symptahy with dollar figures. The infrastructure costs in the New Orleans area are going to be massive but an appropriate expenditure of government funds. You pay taxes so that are roads, schools, fire, police, etc. Those need to be rebuilt, restocked and re-inforced.

Put when the government starts rebuilding homes for private citizens I put my damn foot down. This is the proverbial road to hell paved with good intentions. If that makes me callous, I don't care. I'd rather be callous and maintain a proper idea of the role of government, then be caring and open Pandora's box.

I care about the million and a half residents of the New Orleans area, but I care about the 290+ million residents of this country who don't live there too, and turning our government into "the big checking account that releases us from any worry" is a recipe for disaster for all of us.

Beth said...

Put when the government starts rebuilding homes for private citizens I put my damn foot down.

Well, you can calm down and stop stamping your little foot, then. The government isn't rebuilding homes in Louisiana or Mississippi. They ARE paying to bulldoze the ones that can't be repaired, providing trailers for people while they either rebuild or relocate (there's a time limit; the trailers are not indefinite), and some people with major damage are getting a small cash settlement--deducted against their insurance, and nowhere near the value of even a modest, matchstick home. If a person is without insurance, it's unlikely they'll be able to rebuild.

What we need money for, and quick, is to fix the levees and canals, and restore that infrastructure you acknowledge is appropriately addressed with federal funds.

Anonymous said...

Charlestoncheap columbia jackets. turned a pair of double plays to do the trick. spyder jacketsThe had at least one runner on in every inning but the first and outhit the RiverDogs by a 12-6 margin Lawal should be a focal point of the Yellow cheap polo shirts along with highly touted newcomer, 6-9 Derrick Favors, rated as the No. 1 power forward on the ESPNU 100. The Yellow JacketsThere are ed hardy shirts pretty ed hardy shirt for men,
ed hardy womens in the ed hardy online storedesigned by ed hardy ,many cheap ed hardy shirt ,glasses,caps,trouers ed hardy shirts on sale ,You can go to edhardyshirts.com to have a look ,you may find one of ed hardy clothing fit

Anonymous said...

I like the side of the article, and very like your blog, to write well and hope to continue their efforts, we can see more of your articles. ed hardy clothes. After reading this article has strong feelings, the future will be Changlaikankan's.ed hardy swimwear. polo hoodies
ed hardy jeans
ed hardy
ed hardy clothing
ed hardy t-shirts
ed hardy clothes
ed-hardy.co.uk
ed hardy shirts
ed hardy mens
ed hardy womens
ed hardy sunglasses
ed hardy swimwear
ed hardy Jeans
ed hardy hoodies
ed hardy bags
ed hardy trousers
ed hardy shoes
ed hardy sunglasses
ed hardy suits
ed
hardy
ed hardy dresses

Anonymous said...

we have lots of polo shirts
Abercrombie Fitch

clothing

Abercrombie Fitch

hoodile

ralph lauren shirts
Columbia Jacket
north face jackets
spyder ski jacket
polo shirts
polo shirt
spyder jackets
spyder jacket
mens spyder jackets
spyder jackets for cheap
spyder ski jacket
womens spyder jackets
ralph lauren
spyder jackets cheap
spyder jackets for men
cheap spyder jackets
north face jackets
discount spyder jacket
ralph lauren t shirts
ralph lauren polo shirts on sale
discount ralph lauren polo shirts
ralph lauren shirts
ralph lauren polo discount
ralph lauren polo sale
ralph lauren polo

shirts

ralph lauren polo wholesale
north face jackets
north face jacket
Columbia Jacket
ralph lauren

jacket

Abercrombie Fitch hoodile
Abercrombie Fitch clothing
abercrombie fitch
abercrombie fitch


welcom to our store.

Anonymous said...

Truly a nice blog and excellent anylasis.I like it! Wish you a nice day! I like orange nike shox tl1 shoes ,I like to buy the cheap nike shoes by the internet shop . the puma shoes and the adidas shoes (or addidas shoes) are more on internet shop .i can buy the cheap nike shoes and cheap puma shoes online. It’s really convenient.
Many persons more like Puma basket shoes than nike air rift shoes . the Puma Cat shoes is a kind of Cheap Puma Shoes .

Anonymous said...

edhardyis the world famouse clothing brand famouse for the mens edhardy shirt , mens edhardy jacket mens edhardy shirt mens edhardy jeanswomens edhardy boots women long sleeve shirted hardy accessories

Anonymous said...

Website logo design | brochure logo design | Custom Logo Design

Anonymous said...

animated logos | Stationery Logo Design

Anonymous said...

cheap nike shox
jeans diesel
Tn Requin
Tennis Racquet
ed hardy

Anonymous said...

Nike Air Rift
chaussures puma
polo shirts

Anonymous said...

The North Face Jackets
Cheap Nike Shoes

Anonymous said...

Air Shoes
Tennis Racquet Shop
Cheap Polo Shirts

Anonymous said...

Wholesale Polo Shirts
cheap polo shirts
Polo Shirts

Anonymous said...

Chaussures Sports
Chaussures Nike
Ed Hardy clothing
Air Max
wholesale polo shirts

Anonymous said...

NFL Jerseys
Affliction Jeans
NFL Jerseys
Air Jordan Shoes
Chaussure de Sport

Anonymous said...

China Wholesale
tn chaussures
nike tn
ed hardy clothing
cheap ed hardy
Chaussures Sport
Chaussures Sport
tn requin
Air Jordan Shoes
NFL Jerseys
MBT shoes
nike tn

Anonymous said...

ankh royalty

ankhroyalty

ankh royalty clothing

ankh royalty sweats

ankh royalty tracksuits
babyliss
babyliss pro
babyliss hair
babyliss i trim
babyliss flat iron
babyliss you curl
babyliss hair straighteners
babyliss hair straightener
babyliss straightener
babyliss straighteners
babyliss portability
babyliss straightening irons
babyliss hair iron
babyliss straightening iron

Anonymous said...

Chanel Sunglasses
Coach Sunglasses
D&G Sunglasses
Dior Sunglasses
ED Hardy Sunglasses
Fendi Sunglasses
LV Sunglasses
Oakley Sunglasses
Police Sunglasses
Ray Ban Sunglasses
Roberto Cavalli Sunglasses
Versace Sunglasses
air max,Nike air max
air max 90
nike air max 90
air max 1
air max 95
nike air max 360
nike air max ltd
air max ltd
air max 360
air max classic,Air Max Huarache
air max light
air max bw
air max plus
air max 180
air max nike
air max TN
air max 87
timberland
timberland boots
timberland shoes
cheap timberland boots
timberland uk
timberlands
timberland 2010
timberland outlet

admin said...

Your blog came up in my search and I’m stricken by what you have written on this subject.
I am currently branching out my search and thus cannot contribute further, still, I have bookmarked your website and will be returning to keep up with any upcoming updates.

trustme said...

Hello, wonderful blog!thank you. By the way,here we offer a lot of good nike shoes,you can come to have

a look.
nike shox r5
nike air max 180
nike nouvelle
tn chaussures
nike tn
tn chaussures
nike air max
pour nike air max 91
shox oz
MBT
nike nouvelle collection
air max tn
nike air max 97
nike store
nike dunk sb high
nike air max
MBT France
basket nike enfant
tn chaussures
nike air max
enfant chaussures
wholesale nike dunk
achat chaussures nike homme nouvelle collection
air max 91
nouvelle requin tn
nike dunk sb
basket nike shox
nike air max 180
MBT chaussures

Unknown said...

Thanks for your post , it is very nice and helpful . all our products are top quality and low prices . would you like something ? ok follow me !
NFL Jerseys
tn chaussures
Thanks for sharing . great article .

Anonymous said...

jordan shoes
cheap jordan shoes
air jordan 1
air jordan 2
air jordan 3
air jordan 4
air jordan 5
air jordan 6
air jordan 7
air jordan 8
air jordan 9
air jordan 10
air jordan 11
air jordan 12
air jordan 13
air jordan 14
air jordan 15
air jordan 16
air jordan 17
air jordan 18
air jordan 19
air jordan 20
air jordan 21
air jordan 22
air jordan 23
Michael Jackson memorial

Unknown said...

An old adage applies to some of the outrageous statements made by some people in the wake of the Katrina tragedyThanks for your post , it is very nice and helpful . all our products are top quality and low prices . would you like something ? ok follow me ! better choice better life !
NFL Jerseys
tn chaussures
Thanks for sharing . great article . all our products are top quality and low prices .
would you like something to buy ? for example clothes and shoes . ok ! follow me !
chaussures puma
Tn Requin
Cheap Polo Shirts
better choice better life !Thanks for your post , it is very nice and helpful .

Unknown said...

Thanks for your great post . it help me a lot ! but I have something to share with you too ! you can login our website to look around , all our products are top quality and low prices . would you like to buy something ? ok follow me ! better choice better life ! do not leave something to regret in yourfuture!
Cheap Polo
Air Max
Nike Chaussures
Chaussures Sport
NFL Jerseys
China Wholesale
Thanks, it is very nice and helpful .i agree with you very much ! but I have something to share with you too ! you can login our website to look around , all our products are top quality and low prices . would you like to buy something ? ok follow me ! better choice better life ! do not leave something to regret in yourfuture!
NFL Jerseys
tn chaussures
chaussures puma
Tn Requin
Cheap Polo Shirts
chaussures pas cher
better choice better life !Thanks for your post , it is very nice and helpful .see you !

Christian Hymon said...

hi,buddy.thanks for the post,a nice job and be keepin' eyes on it.

Air Max Chaussures

Air Max Chaussures

Air Max 1 Chaussures

Air Max light chaussures

Air Max 90 chaussures

Air 180 chaussures

Air classic BW chaussures

Air max 93 chaussures

Air max 95 chaussures

Air max 97 chaussures

Air max 360 chaussures

Air Max Schuhe

Air Max 2009 Schuhe

Air max ltd chaussures

Air max tn chaussures

aai333 said...

Nice article written by you
Nicediscount nike dunk
articlecheap nike shoes
writtennike dunk outlet
byChristian Louboutin shoes
youChloe outlet
cheap Chloe bags
discount Chloe bags
newest Chloe shoes
Chloe bags 2010
Chloe totes
bape shoes outlet
bape clothing
discount bape shoes
cheap bape shoes
bape jackets
wholesale ed hardy
ed hardy wholesale
discount ed hardy
MBT boots
MBT shoes in fashion
cheap mbt shoes sale
discount mbt outlet 2010
MBT Walking Shoes
Purple GHD
Moncler
Moncler jackets
Moncler coats
Moncler Vest
Moncler outlet
discount moncler Tshirt
air jordan 2010
cheap jordan shoes
discount jordan shoes
jump man 23
cheap ugg boots
discount ugg boots
ugg boots

ai said...

ugg boots
polo boots
polo shoes

herve leger
herve leger handage dress

chanel outlet
chanel handbags
chanel bags
chanel iman

ralph Lauren polo
ralph lauren outlet
lacoste polo
polo raplh lauren

air jordan 2010
cheap jordan shoes
jordan ajf shoes
discount jordan shoes
jumpman23

moncler
moncler jackets
moncler coats
moncler vest
moncler outlet
moncler Polo t shirt
cheap five finger shoes

kiss ghd

Michelle said...

This is the best glasses article I have ever found on the Internet.

This eyewear article is definitely eye-opening and inspiring.

You have given us some interesting points on eyeglasses online. This is a wonderful article and surely worth reading.

Excellent point here. I wish there are more and more cheap eyeglasses articles like that.

It has been long before I can find some useful articles about prescription glasses. Your views truly open my mind.

We share the opinion on cheap kids glasses and I really enjoy reading your article.

I appreciate your bright ideas in this child eyeglasses article. Great work!

Good job for writing this brilliant article of children eyeglasses.

Bright idea, hope there can be more useful articles about kids sunglasses .

I really like this unisex glasses article, and hope there can be more great resources like this.

Great article, it's helpful to me, and I also like the useful info about metal eyeglasses.

I totally agree with you on the point of plastic eyewear. This is a nice article for sure.

I am glad to read some fantastic titanium eyewear article like this.

Thank you so much for sharing some great ideas of aviator eyeglasses with us, they are helpful.

I love this rimless glasses article since it is one of those which truly convey useful ideas.

Michelle said...

I love this glasses article since it is one of those which truly convey useful ideas.

What an inspiring article you wrote! I totally like the useful eyewear info shared in the article.

Your do have some unique ideas here and I expect more eyeglasses online articles from you.

I am glad to read some fantastic cheap eyeglasses article like this.

Great resources of prescription glasses! Thank you for sharing this with us.

This is the best cheap kids glasses article I have ever found on the Internet.

Thank you so much for sharing some great ideas of child eyeglasses with us, they are helpful.

We share the opinion on children eyeglasses and I really enjoy reading your article.

I greatly benefit from your articles every time I read one. Thanks for the kids sunglasses info, it helps a lot.

I appreciate your bright ideas in this unisex glasses article. Great work!

Good job for writing this brilliant article of metal eyeglasses.

Excellent point here. I wish there are more and more plastic eyewear articles like that.

Bright idea, hope there can be more useful articles about titanium eyewear.

Great article, it's helpful to me, and I also like the useful info about aviator eyeglasses.

I really like this rimless glasses article, and hope there can be more great resources like this.

Anonymous said...

vibram kso
vibram running shoes
MBT boots
MBT shoes in fashion
cheap mbt shoes sale
discount mbt outlet 2010
MBT Walking Shoes

spyder
spyder jackets
spyder ski wear
coach outlet
coach handbag
coach handbags
coach bag
coach bags


spyder
spyder jackets
spyder ski wear

spyder
spyder jackets
spyder ski wear

ugg boots
ugg boots cheap
discount ugg boots
classic ugg boots
ugg classic tall boots
GHD Mini Styler

cheap ugg boots
discount ugg boots
ugg boots
classic ugg boots
ugg classic tall boots

ripple said...

I have never read so wonderful article before,after read your article I learned more,thanks a lot!
lyle and scott polo shirt
mens lyle and scott
cheap lyle and scott
lyle and scott jacket
lyle and scott wholesale
puma Future cat
femmes mbt chaussures
puma Drift cat
Nike Air Max 2009
Nike Air Max 360
Nike Air Max TN
Nike Air Max
Nike Air Max TN Dollar
Nike Shox NZ
Nike Shox R4
Nike Shox Torche
Nike Air Max TN 2
Nike Air Max TN
Nike Shox R4
MBT kisumu sandal
discount mbt chaussure
mbt chaussure wholesale
puma Kart cat
nike tn requins
MBT CHAUSSURE FEMME
MBT CHAUSSURE HOMME
MBT KISUMU sandal
Nike Shox R4
Nike Shox R4 Cartoon
Nike blazer high
Nike blazer low
Nike Tn Net
Nike Air Max 360

Anonymous said...

I have never read so wonderful article before,I have learned more after read your article,thanks a lot!By the way,we

sale the best shoes in my onlion shop.it will give your live lovely.
tn requin
nike shox r4
nike shox running shoes
lyle and scott wholesale
mbt walking shoes
cheap ed hardy

Anonymous said...

Can you look at an item of the designer handbags for a long time but it is so bright as to hurt your eyes? This is the one I am going to talk about, the Fendi Calfhair and Sequin Shoulder Bag. Just at the first glance, can louis vuitton neverfull mm justify the price of it? Louis Vuitton Damier Azur Galliera GM have seen a lot of sequins bag before, but this vernis alma can come to the top of so many. There are part of the louis vuitton handbags that I simply can not abide, but this louis vuitton speedy bag, though bright to hurt my eyes, still enchants me.

Unknown said...

Young and creative style
abercrombie and fitch
You can have a look at it.
abercrombie & fitch
if you really want it
jordan 8
jordan 9
jordan 10

Anonymous said...

china wholesale
wholesale golf clubs
wholesale handbags
wholesale cell phones
wholesale power balance
wholesale ipod accessories
wholesale memory cards
wholesale sporting goods
wholesale Wedding dresses
wholesale jewelry
Most Salable Golf Products at Unparalleled Price
Summer Cool Wear and Decoration Accessories
2010 FIFA World Cup South Africa
linkchinablog

combattery84 said...

Acer ASPIRE 1300 battery
Acer ASPIRE 1310 battery
Acer Aspire 1410 battery
Acer ASPIRE 1680 battery
ACER BTP-63D1 battery
ACER BTP-43D1 battery
Acer lc.btp05.001 battery
Acer aspire 3000 battery
Acer Travelmate 4000 battery
ACER aspire 5560 battery
ACER BATBL50L6 battery
ACER TravelMate 240 Battery
ACER BT.00803.004 Battery
ACER Travelmate 4002lmi battery
Acer travelmate 800 battery
Acer aspire 3613wlmi battery
Travelmate 2414wlmi battery
Acer batcl50l battery
Acer Travelmate 2300 battery
ACER aspire 3610 battery
ACER travelmate 4600 battery
Dell Latitude D800 battery
Dell Inspiron 600m battery
Dell Inspiron 8100 Battery
Dell Y9943 battery
Dell Inspiron 1521 battery

combattery84 said...

Dell Inspiron 510m battery
Dell Latitude D500 battery
Dell Latitude D520 battery
Dell GD761 battery
Dell NF343 battery
Dell D5318 battery
Dell G5260 battery
Dell Inspiron 9200 battery
Dell Latitude C500 battery
Dell HD438 Battery
Dell GK479 battery
Dell PC764 battery
Dell KD476 Battery
Dell Inspiron 1150 battery
Dell inspiron 8500 battery
Dell Inspiron 4100 battery
Dell Inspiron 4000 battery
Dell Inspiron 8200 battery
Dell FK890 battery
Dell Inspiron 1721 battery
Dell Inspiron 1300 Battery
Dell Inspiron 1520 Battery
Dell Latitude D600 Battery
Dell XPS M1330 battery
Dell Latitude D531N Battery
Dell INSPIRON 6000 battery
Dell INSPIRON 6400 Battery
Dell Inspiron 9300 battery

combattery84 said...

SONY PCGA-BP4V battery
SONY PCGA-BP71 battery
SONY PCGA-BP71A battery
SONY VGP-BPL1 battery
SONY VGP-BPL2 battery
Sony vgn-t2xp/s battery
Sony vaio vgn-s4xp battery
Sony vaio pcg-z1rsp battery
SONY NP-FT1 battery
SONY NP-FC10 Battery
SONY NP-F330 Battery
SONY NP-F550 Battery
SONY NP-FM50 Battery
SONY NP-FP50 Battery
SONY NP-55 Battery
SONY NP-FM70 Battery
SONY NP-33 Battery
SONY NP-F970 Battery
SONY NP-FP90 Battery
FUJITSU Lifebook C2220 battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp63 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp68 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp77 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp78 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp79 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp95 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp98 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp121 Battery
FUJITSU Fpcbp151 Battery
FUJITSU lifebook t4010 Battery

combattery84 said...

FUJITSU lifebook t4020d Battery
GATEWAY NX7000 battery
UNIWILL 258-4S4400-S1P1 Battery
TOSHIBA PA3307U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3383U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3384U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3465U-1BRS Battery
Toshiba PA2487UR battery
Toshiba A100 Battery
Toshiba Satellite A105 battery
Toshiba A70 battery
PA3062U-1BAT battery
Toshiba Satellite P30 battery
Toshiba PA3084U-1BRS battery
Toshiba PA3098U battery
PA3107U-1BAS battery
PA3107U-1BRS battery
PA3166U-1BRS battery
PA3176U-1BAS battery
TOSHIBA PABAS076 Battery
Toshiba pa3399u-1brs battery
TOSHIBA PA3399U-2BAS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3421U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3456U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA Pa3356u-1brs battery
Satellite a10 battery
Pa3331u-1brs battery

combattery84 said...

FUJITSU lifebook t4020d Battery
GATEWAY NX7000 battery
UNIWILL 258-4S4400-S1P1 Battery
TOSHIBA PA3307U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3383U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3384U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3465U-1BRS Battery
Toshiba PA2487UR battery
Toshiba A100 Battery
Toshiba Satellite A105 battery
Toshiba A70 battery
PA3062U-1BAT battery
Toshiba Satellite P30 battery
Toshiba PA3084U-1BRS battery
Toshiba PA3098U battery
PA3107U-1BAS battery
PA3107U-1BRS battery
PA3166U-1BRS battery
PA3176U-1BAS battery
TOSHIBA PABAS076 Battery
Toshiba pa3399u-1brs battery
TOSHIBA PA3399U-2BAS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3421U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA PA3456U-1BRS Battery
TOSHIBA Pa3356u-1brs battery
Satellite a10 battery
Pa3331u-1brs battery

Anonymous said...

More and more chi flat irons women began to take care of yourself, chi flat iron more power to facilitate the sweet heaviness of the body all the basics of stress, give it a few times, aromatherapy massage, it is very

necessary.Using chi Straightening ironsD to manage their hair, as the management of aromatherapy massage body.Ghd relaxants for you so unbelievable.

clarebear said...

We are China online Wholesale Beads store, China Wholesale Beads is your best choice. We offer you Jewelry Supplies, Jewelry Findings, Jewelry Beads at the cheapest price. We are specialized in Wholesale Jewelry Supplies, Wholesale Jewelry Findings, Tibetan Style Beads, Acrylic Beads, Crystal Beads, Jewelry Charms, Pandora Style Beads, Lampwork Beads, Metal Beads, Gemstone Beads, Wood & Nut Beads. Buy more get more discount.
hr

Unknown said...

nice share thanks a lot :)

download free pc games
affiliate review

luck said...

Is an exclusive “Y” repeat pattern, Nike Shoes Us, Nike Air Max Shoes,"Nike air max 2011,as either a debossed or Nike Air Max 1 lasered detail, Air Max Griffey 1 which takes inspiration from the Nike Air Max 180 Jordan brands iconic Nike Air Max 2009 Elephant print material.Nike Air Max 2010 This graphic treatment was developed by West and Smith to pay tribute not only to the name of the Nike Air Max 24 7 and it’s co-creator, but also to the various moments in history that spurred West’s initial inspiration for the Ni Nike Air Max 87,Nike Air Max 90,Nike Air Max 2011,Nike Air Max Shoes,Nike Air Max 91,Nike Air Max BW,Nike Air Max Plus TN,Nike Air Max LTD,
Nike Air Max Boots,Nike Air Max Presto,Nike Air Max Skyline,Nike Air Max Turbulence,Nike Air Max Fitsole,Nike Air Max Goadome,Nike Air Max Zenyth,Nike Air Max Wildwood Supreme,Nike Air Max Zoom Kobe.

Anonymous said...

The Christian Louboutin Heels can help you become sexy and elegant. christian louboutin 2011 sandals are regarded since the symbolic representation of attractive and elegant.christian louboutin wedgesIt is especially suitable for the women who wear the christian louboutin evening shoes at the first time. These christian louboutin pumps combine top quality, reasonable price and fashional design, which is your best choice Artist who promoted his collection of luxury christian louboutin classic
in earlier 90s. No 1 can disregard the existence in the style world, World-famous red-colored soles and christian louboutin peep toe are shaped features. However, you can by no means overlook the beautiful. You do not even need to go inside environment, as well as your slim,christian louboutin thong sandalsgorgeous and graceful legs may be effortlessly discovered in people's eyes.!Welcome to our christian louboutin store.

eaststarsale 01 said...

Oakley Sunglasseswill be the shining star this month ,also maybe last to the end of this summer. Shining star Cheap Oakley Sunglassesnot only cheap oakley sunglasses ,but alsoOakley Sunglasses Cheap in high quality and perfect design. With the best service and fast transportation we always ensured our customers benefit and will also do it in the later time.

eaststarsale 01 said...

Oakley Sunglasseswill be the shining star this month ,also maybe last to the end of this summer. Shining star Cheap Oakley Sunglassesnot only cheap oakley sunglasses ,but alsoOakley Sunglasses Cheap in high quality and perfect design. With the best service and fast transportation we always ensured our customers benefit and will also do it in the later time.

eaststarsale 01 said...

Reebok Easytone will be the shining star this month ,also maybe last to the end of this summer. Shining starZigTech Sale not only Reebok Easytone ,but also Reebok ZigTech With the best service and fast transportation we always ensured our customers benefit and will also do it in the later time

eaststarsale 02 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Al Gorgon said...

Thanks for the information. This is a wonderful post!!
A Level Coursework

Frank said...

Hey,
Loving your blog, awesome tips on blog you have here. I
would just like to ask you some questions privately, mind real player 11,IDM Free Download,function venues geelong,la Fitness locations,la Fitness

Logo Design London said...

Brillant post and a blog! Thank you very much for sharing

Logo Design

Logo Design said...

This eyewear article is definitely eye-opening and inspiring.I am glad to read some fantastic like this article.Logo Design

Anonymous said...

Costa Rica Fishing
As a result of Hurricane Katrina and its effects on New Orleans, Tulane University was closed for the second time in its history—the first being during the American Civil War. The university closed for four months during Katrina, as compared with four years during the Civil War.

Costa Rica Fishing and Tours
The School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine's distance learning programs and courses stayed active.

http://costa-ricafishing.com/
Prior to Katrina, Tulane University was the largest private employer in the city of New Orleans; immediately afterward it became the city's single largest employer of any type - public or private.

Evacuation

Costa Rica Wedding
Tulane began to publicly respond to the arrival of Hurricane Katrina on August 27, 2005, with an initial plan to close the university until September 1. The following day, that date was extended to "no earlier than" September 7. University officials led a rare evacuation of nearly 400 students (one report said that the number was closer to 700) to Jackson State University, all of whom remained safe after the hurricane's passage and returned to their homes if they were from outside the gulf coast region. This was the second time Tulane's evacuation plan had been used, the first being in September 2004 during Hurricane Ivan. In other recent hurricanes such as Georges in 1998, Tulane simply used its larger dorms as shelters for students.

Costa Rica Fishing
During the storm, Tulane University Hospital & Clinic lost power and received patients from neighboring hospitals and from the Louisiana Superdome. These patients, along with all hospital staff, staff family members present, and patients were evacuated within five days via helicopters from the top floor of a neighboring parking garage. This rescue effort was organized, directed, and paid for by the hospital's parent company, HCA. On February 14, 2006 it was the first hospital to reopen in downtown New Orleans after the hurricane.
Costa Rica Fishing and Tours
http://costa-ricafishing.com/
Costa Rica Wedding

Audery Walters said...

A professionally crafted logo designs is one of the greatest blessings for a company; whether it is big or small. It gives them an identity of their own and makes them different from others.logo design

Derek Gendron said...

really amazing blog book marked it thanks for sharing.


design a business logo

Derek Gendron said...

nice to see this post thanks for sharing just book marked for my future inspiration.
logo design inspiration

Unknown said...

Get A Wider Range Of Pleasure Toys Click On The Link XTC Supercenter Bradenton